Ready for some of the best Bloody Marys in Wisconsin? We get that for some folks, these accouterment-filled bloody marys are a bit too much. Bloody Mary purists don’t love this fad of putting a whole meal in a Bloody as a garnish. This article is not for those people. Those folks can enjoy their spicy, spiked tomato juice at one of these awesome places and be quite happy. But if you love outrageous, ridiculous, how-will-they-top-that Bloody Marys, the following list is for you. Sobelman’s started this trend by putting a fried chicken on a stick and calling it a Bloody Mary garnish and the rest of Wisconsin was not going to be outdone in scale or creativity. All across the state, folks are coming up with increasingly unusual and over-the-top ways to serve up a Bloody Mary and you’re going to want to check them out.

1. Sobelman's - Milwaukee
Facebook/Sobelman's
I'm sure there were places with unique garnishes, but the folks at Sobelman's pioneered the idea of including brunch IN the glass and they inspired folks everywhere to dream big. This Bloody Mary is bigger than your head and requires a few friends to get it down. From bacon-wrapped jalapeno cheese balls to sliders and of course, the whole darn chicken, this is really the monster and the outrageous Bloody Mary to which all other Bloodys are compared. They have three Milwaukee-area locations: 1900 W St Paul Ave., Milwaukee, WI 53233, 1601 W Wells St., Milwaukee, WI 53233, and 10352 N. Port Washington Rd., Mequon, WI 53092.
Click here for more information about this Wisconsin restaurant.
2. The Tavern on Central - Florence
Facebook/TheTavernonCentral
The T.O.C. Bloody Mary is 22oz and is garnished with a cheeseburger slider, cheese cubes, a beef stick, string cheese, a pickled egg, pickled Brussels sprout, mushrooms, olives, & a pickle and comes with a beer chaser. This one definitely serves as a brunch meal all on its own. Located at 500 Central Ave., Florence, WI 54121.
Click here for more information about this Wisconsin restaurant.
3. Smashed on the Rocks - Algoma
Facebook/Smashed on the Rocks
You'll find a soft pretzel, corn dog, mozzarella whips, pepperoncini, cold cuts, a slider, lots of cheese, a whole stalk of celery, and more in this over-the-top and still delicious Bloody Mary. Out of the best Bloody Marys in Wisconsin, this one might win the award for most enthusiastic. Located at 70 Church St., Algoma, WI 54201.
Click here for more information about this Wisconsin restaurant.
4. St. Paul Fish Market - Milwaukee
Facebook/St. PaulFish
What else would you expect to find in a Bloody Mary at a fish market other than a lobster claw? There's also smoked salmon jerky (which they call the bacon of the sea world), shrimp, and more. Located inside the Milwaukee Public Market at 400 N Water St., Milwaukee, WI 53202
Click here for more information about this Wisconsin restaurant.
5. Hoozels - Wisconsin Rapids
Facebook/Hoozels
This Bloody is so big it requires its own tray. At 51 ounces, it's no joke. You'll find all kinds of fried goodies on here, including chicken and waffles, cheese curds, mini peppers, and dipping sauces! Located at 4010 Plover Rd., Wisconsin Rapids, WI 54494.
Click here for more information about this Wisconsin restaurant.
6. The Nitty Gritty - Madison
Facebook/NittyGrittyMadison
Described as one full liter of Bloody Mary garnished with a sausage link, a slice of cherrywood smoked bacon, beef stick, cheese curd, pickle, and olive, and topped off with a mini version of the famous Gritty Burger, Brunchzilla Bloody Mary at the Nitty Gritty also comes with a chaser: a whole pint of a beer of your choice. Located at 223 N Frances St., Madison, WI 53703.
Click here for more information about this Wisconsin restaurant.

Related Stories

The Massive Burgers At Samuelson's Creek Pub And Grill In Wisconsin Are Sure To Satisfy Even The Biggest Of Appetites

The Massive Burgers At Samuelson's Creek Pub And Grill In Wisconsin Are Sure To Satisfy Even The Biggest Of Appetites

 Burgers Bar In Wisconsin Has Over 30 Different Burgers To Choose From

Burgers Bar In Wisconsin Has Over 30 Different Burgers To Choose From

 Maxwell Mansion Speakeasy Is The Underground Cocktail Lounge In Wisconsin You Have To Visit

Maxwell Mansion Speakeasy Is The Underground Cocktail Lounge In Wisconsin You Have To Visit
7. Sprecher's Pub - Lake Geneva
Facebook/SprechersLakeGeneva
Please note, Sprecher's Pub has permanently closed.

Here you'll find a 32-oz Bloody Mary garnished with their version of a Scotch Egg, which is wrapped in bratwurst meat. Plus thick bacon, a pretzel, lots of cheese, and more. Located at 111 Center St., Lake Geneva, WI 53147.
Click here for more information about this Wisconsin restaurant.
8. Two of a Kind - Kaukauna
Facebook/TwoofAKind
Another meal in a glass, this one comes with onion rings, a slider, shrimp, mozzarella whips, a shrimp, and more. Located at W3220 Dundas Rd., Kaukauna, WI 54130.
Click here for more information about this Wisconsin restaurant.
9. Kathy's Buffalo Bar - Watertown
Facebook/Kathy'sBuffaloBar
They call this the Bloody Mary Breakfast and it has 18 different garnishes, from a slider and cheese to radishes, a meatball, and more. Located at 814 N Church St., Watertown, WI 53098.
Click here for more information about this Wisconsin restaurant.
10. Anduzzi's Sports Club - Green Bay
Facebook/AnduzzisSportsClub
One of their locations is right across from Lambeau, so it's not surprising that one of these garnish picks actually looks like football uprights. There's also a buffalo chicken slider, a hamburger slider, chicken wings, corn dogs, shrimp, pickles, olives, a meatball, lots of cheese, and more. These folks have three Green Bay-area locations: 900 Kepler Dr., Green Bay, WI 54311, 1992 Holmgren Way, Green Bay, WI 54304, and 2555 Lineville Rd., Green Bay, WI 54313.
Click here for more information about this Wisconsin restaurant.
11. Big T's Saloon - Eau Claire
Facebook/BigTsSaloon
In addition to cold cuts, the longest pick of cheese, olives, and other standards, plus a meat stick, this one comes with some sweet components to help wrap up your meal. Located at 2007 3rd St., Eau Claire, WI 54703.
Click here for more information about this Wisconsin restaurant.
12. Mulligan's - Mountain
Facebook/MulligansMountain
If you can pickle it, Mulligan's has put it on their Bloody. This one features pickled egg, Brussels sprouts, tomato, green beans, smoked sausage stick, mozzarella cheese stick, pickled cauliflower, pretzels, garlic bread, pickled carrot slices, dill pickle Spear, celery, and more. Located at 16707 WI-32, Mountain, WI 54149.
Click here for more information about this Wisconsin restaurant.
13. The Wicked Hop - Milwaukee
Facebook The Wicked Hop
Actually voted by residents as being one of the best Bloody Marys in Wisconsin, The Wicked Hop features giant cocktails at half price on Saturday mornings! Make sure to get yours topped with summer sausage and cheese whips. Located at 345 N Broadway, Milwaukee, WI 53202.
Click here for more information about this Wisconsin restaurant.

Where are your favorites from this list of best Bloody Marys in Wisconsin? Let us know in the comments!

What sort of crazy garnishes would you like to find in a Bloody Mary that you haven’t seen before?

Big thanks to the Wisconsin Bloody Mary Aficionados Facebook Group for showing off some of the state’s great crazy Bloody Marys.

OnlyInYourState may earn compensation through affiliate links in this article. As an Amazon Associate, we earn from qualifying purchases.

More to Explore

Best Bloody Marys In Wisconsin

Marisa Roman | March 08, 2021

What is the most popular brunch restaurant in Wisconsin?

When the weekend rolls around, sometimes it’s hard to think about anything but finding the best brunch in Wisconsin. Picture platters of pancakes, crispy bacon, or a seafood omelet loaded with Wisconsin cheese. If you want to experience one of the best brunches in Wisconsin then head on over to Harbor House in Milwaukee. For one low admission price, you’ll get all-you-can-eat seafood fresh, with amazing waterfront views.

What are the local favorite restaurants in Wisconsin?

Finding the best local restaurants in Wisconsin isn’t too hard, especially since the smaller towns and cities within the state have some charming mom-and-pop spots that locals love. In fact, there are so many classic Wisconsin restaurants, we’ve compiled a list of the best of them. Check out these 18 scrumptious Wisconsin restaurants that are classics.

What is the most popular restaurant in Wisconsin?

If you’re visiting the Cheese State for the first time, you’re probably trying to figure out where to dine in Wisconsin that will elevate your trip. Oftentimes, finding the most popular restaurant will bring about a beloved dining experience that will show you an authentic side of the state. In Wisconsin, that popular restaurant experience is The Immigrant Restaurant in Kohler. This AAA Four Diamond Award Winner boasts a truly memorable experience and is fine dining at its best.

Related Articles

Explore Wisconsin

Featured Addresses
1601 W Wells St, Milwaukee, WI 53233, USA
500 Central Ave, Florence, WI 54121, USA
Smashed on the Rocks, 70 Church St, Algoma, WI 54201, USA
St. Paul Fish Company, Milwaukee Public Market, 400 N Water St, Milwaukee, WI 53202, USA
4010 Plover Rd, Wisconsin Rapids, WI 54494, USA
223 N Frances St, Madison, WI 53703, USA
111 Center St, Lake Geneva, WI 53147, USA
W3220 Dundas Rd, Kaukauna, WI 54130, USA
814 N Church St, Watertown, WI 53098, USA
900 Kepler Dr, Green Bay, WI 54311, USA
2007 3rd St, Eau Claire, WI 54703, USA
16707 WI-32, Mountain, WI 54149, USA
345 N Broadway, Milwaukee, WI 53202, USA