10 Scary Good Wisconsin Pizzerias That Belong On Your Bucket List
×
Daniella DiRienzo
Author
When you’re in Wisconsin, great pizza is never too far away. From classic topping combos to innovative pies, we’ve got it all here in the Badger State. Not sure where to begin your quest for the state’s tastiest pies? Well, this list is a good place to start. Read on for 10 Wisconsin pizzerias that are without a doubt bucket list worthy.
If you want more Wisconsin restaurants, make sure to click here and sign up for our weekly dining newsletter. Every Thursday, a new eatery to try in the Badger State will be delivered straight to your email. Yum!
Not all pizzerias are created equal, and Harry’s Prohibition Bistro is a prime example - it’s one of only a handful of pizzerias throughout the state certified by the Associazione Vera Pizza Napoletana. Meeting the strict requirements of classic Italian Neapolitan pizza-making isn’t the only thing that sets Harry’s apart, though. Throughout the years, it’s become known for its unique flavor pairings, such as corn pizza.
Advertisement
Advertisement
Part of what makes Sam’s so special is that it’s been around for so long – 62 years, to be exact. Only growing in popularity throughout the decades, the pizzeria has garnered a reputation for its thin, crispy crust, quality pies, and affordable prices.
Another longtime favorite, Portesi’s has been serving up fresh, homemade pizza and Italian dinners since 1961! Sure to pique the interest of all palates, the menu features classic pies as well as a slew of creative specialty pizzas, such as shrimp, chicken alfredo, and BBQ chicken.
Another pizzeria certified by the Associazione Vera Pizza Napoletana, Il Ritrovo is sure to impress even the most serious of pizza aficionados. Every pizza on the menu is made with fresh, authentic ingredients, resulting in pies that are delicious and flavorful. The Margherita Classico is the top-seller; however, if you ask a regular, they’ll likely tell you to go with the Giuseppe, which is made with mozzarella, Calabrian chili paste, chopped tomatoes, onions, sopressa salami and mascarpone.
Advertisement
Homemade is the name of the game at this beloved Neenah pizzeria, which has been serving up great pizza since the 1980s. Each and every pie starts off with made-from-scratch dough, which is then topped with an array of flavorful sauces, fresh veggies, and meats, including house-made sausage.
Related Stories
Family-Owned Since The 1950s, Step Back In Time At Maria’s Pizza In Wisconsin
Some Of Wisconsin's Best Pizza Is Served Up Daily At This Small Town Restaurant
Wisconsin's First Italian Restaurant Has Literally Been Around Forever
Locals and visitors alike rave about the pizza from The Brothers Three, which regardless of toppings, boasts lots of cheese, crisp crust, and perfectly-seasoned sauce. The tasty selection includes all the classics as well as not-so-classic pies, such as Taco Ole’ and BBQ Chicken.
Advertisement
Pizza isn’t the only thing on the menu at this Two Rivers restaurant; however, it’s a customer favorite – and it’s not hard to see why. Peruse the pizza selection and, while you won’t find a ton of pies, you’ll find several options – all of which feature hearty topping combos.
In business since 1995, Luigi’s has had plenty of time to perfect its pies, which are easily identifiable by their signature crispy, yet chewy, thin crust. Aside from unique pies, such as Taco Pizza, the eatery’s classic pizzas stand out as well, thanks in part to thin-sliced onions, which can be found on top of the pizza, delivering a burst of flavor that’s sure to satisfy.
If you’re craving a classic Neapolitan pizza, this Madison eatery won’t disappoint. A customer favorite, the Neapolitan pies are made completely in-house – from the crust to the sauce to the mozzarella cheese.
Advertisement
Novanta translates to "ninety" in Italian, which references the 90 seconds it takes for the eatery’s signature stone-baked Neapolitan pizzas to cook. Aside from a quick turn-around time, the pies at Novanta are revered for their crust, which is made using an ancient Italian recipe.
So, what do you think? Are these pizzerias worthy of being deemed among the best? Did we miss your favorite pizza spot? Tell us in the comments section.
Looking for another can’t-miss pizzeria? Click here.
OnlyInYourState may earn compensation through affiliate links in this article. As an Amazon Associate, we earn from qualifying purchases.
Featured Addresses
668 S Pier Dr, Sheboygan, WI 53081, USA
111 Elm St, Wausau, WI 54401, USA
4110 8th St S, Wisconsin Rapids, WI 54494, USA
515 S 8th St, Sheboygan, WI 53081, USA
124 W Wisconsin Ave, Neenah, WI 54956, USA
106 Superior Ave, Oconto, WI 54153, USA
6421 County Rd O # 2, Two Rivers, WI 54241, USA
607 S Main St, Shawano, WI 54166, USA
1805 Monroe St, Madison, WI 53711, USA
8452 Old Sauk Rd, Middleton, WI 53562, USA