In Northern Door County, you’re far away from the big fast-food chains, which might just be part of why you’re there. But as you stroll the postcard-perfect villages, you might find yourself a little hungry, and perhaps a little short on time. The solution is waiting for you in a charming store in the heart of Fish Creek. Fish Creek Market is a longtime business with an offering that can’t be beaten – the best sandwiches in Wisconsin that will fuel all of your Door County adventures.

If you want more Wisconsin restaurants, make sure to sign up for our weekly dining newsletter. Every Thursday, a new eatery to try in the Badger State will be delivered straight to your email. Yum!

Is a perfect sandwich more than the sum of its parts? If you taste one of the sandwiches at Fish Creek Market you might think so. Because on paper, they might seem like a sandwich you could order just about anywhere.
Facebook / Fish Creek Market
But this sandwich shop is not just anywhere, and that might help explain why these sandwiches are so cherished. The Fish Creek Mercantile has been located in a beautiful old building in, a wonderful location for more than 125 years.
Facebook / Fish Creek Market
The Fish Creek market offers everything you might need to fuel your vacation, including beverages, provisions, and souvenirs to bring home. But one of the best things sold here involves bread and fillings.
Facebook / Fish Creek Market

Related Stories

Most People Don’t Know There’s A World Famous Orange Couch In Wisconsin

Most People Don’t Know There’s A World Famous Orange Couch In Wisconsin

 With Its Own Private Playground, This Incredible Cafe In Wisconsin Is Perfect For Families

With Its Own Private Playground, This Incredible Cafe In Wisconsin Is Perfect For Families

 Hungry Crowds Are Chasing This Fish And Chips Truck That’s Rolling Through Wisconsin

Hungry Crowds Are Chasing This Fish And Chips Truck That’s Rolling Through Wisconsin
The market crafts extraordinary sandwiches that have delighted locals and visitors for decades. You can get them in the perfect to-go box, complete with chips and a cookie. The tradition dates back to when most Fish Creek residents didn’t have a refrigerator.
Facebook / Fish Creek Market
Once you have your sandwich box in hand, it’s a short walk to gorgeous spots like the Fish Creek beach and the town dock.
Facebook / Fish Creek Market
Find the perfect view and savor your Fish Creek Market sandwich, one bite at a time. Does the view make the sandwich taste better? Or perhaps your shopping trip to the beautiful old store? You can ponder that as you finish your cookie.
Facebook / Fish Creek Market

I’ve enjoyed many of these sandwiches – it’s been a while but the thought of biting into one of the best sandwiches in Wisconsin still makes me hungry. Learn more about Fish Creek Market on the shop’s website. If you’re planning a getaway, find accommodations on Booking.com.

Here’s where to find more of the best Wisconsin food and dining spots.

OnlyInYourState may earn compensation through affiliate links in this article. As an Amazon Associate, we earn from qualifying purchases.

Related Articles

Explore Wisconsin

Featured Addresses
Fish Creek Market, 4164 Main St, Fish Creek, WI 54212, USA