There’s no middle ground on this sandwich. In Monroe, Wisconsin, a postcard-perfect tavern serves up a sandwich that you’ll smell coming. Baumgartner’s Cheese Store & Tavern has a sandwich that’s anchored by a thick slice of Limburger cheese – yep, the cheese that some say smells like an old sock.

Others disagree and say that all that’s missing from this sandwich is a cold Wisconsin beer.

So what do you think, masterpiece or stink sandwich? Read on and try to make up your mind.

Monroe is a town of about 10,000 in southern Wisconsin that was settled by Swiss immigrants. That heritage is on full display at Baumgartner's, which is located in the center of Monroe on the town square.
Facebook /Baumgartner Cheese Store and Tavern
The cheese store and tavern opened in 1931 and is Wisconsin's oldest cheese store. It's a timeless gathering spot that might remind you of another era.
Facebook /Baumgartner Cheese Store and Tavern
You'll find plenty of locals as well as travelers dropping in. The business has received a ton of publicity, including articles in national publications and an appearance on the Travel Channel.
Facebook /Baumgartner Cheese Store and Tavern

Related Stories

The Beloved Hole-In-The-Wall That Serves The Arguably Best Fried Chicken In All Of Wisconsin

The Beloved Hole-In-The-Wall That Serves The Arguably Best Fried Chicken In All Of Wisconsin

 This Deli Sandwich Hotspot In Wisconsin Has Been Serving Up Some Of The Best German Food Since 1904

This Deli Sandwich Hotspot In Wisconsin Has Been Serving Up Some Of The Best German Food Since 1904

 It's Worth It To Drive Across Wisconsin Just For The Chicken Wings At River Inn Bar

It's Worth It To Drive Across Wisconsin Just For The Chicken Wings At River Inn Bar
A big part of that publicity can be attributed to the sandwich: it's made with local Limburger cheese, a thick slice of red onion, served on dark rye bread. If you're still hungry, feel free to wash it down with cheese and sausage!
Facebook /Baumgartner Cheese Store and Tavern
The restaurant goes through mountains of rye bread, Limburger cheese and local beer. There's a great selection on tap!
Tripadvisor / Jeff. M.
The only way to make up your mind on this sandwich is to try it for yourself, so make plans to head for Baumgartner's - just don't forget the mint!
Tripadvisor / retirees2011

Monroe is the center of cheese and beer country, so a trip to Baumgartner’s can be paired with a trip to a cheese factory or brewery. And don’t miss Cheese Days, held the third weekend of September on even-numbered years. It’s been taking place since 1914 and Baumgartner’s is the center of the action! Once you’ve downed a Limburger sandwich, here are some more sandwiches to try before you die!

OnlyInYourState may earn compensation through affiliate links in this article. As an Amazon Associate, we earn from qualifying purchases.

Related Articles

Explore Wisconsin

Featured Addresses
Baumgartner's Cheese Store & Tavern, 1023 16th Ave, Monroe, WI 53566, USA