For an unforgettably delicious meal in a setting to match, you can’t go wrong with a visit to Maria’s Pizza. A timeless classic, it’s been serving up some of the Midwest’s tastiest thin crust pizza for decades. The pies aren’t the only thing that’s remained a constant, though. Since opening in the 1950s, operating Maria’s Pizza has been a family affair. Take a look:

If you want more Wisconsin restaurants, make sure to click here and sign up for our weekly dining newsletter. Every Thursday, a new eatery to try in the Badger State will be delivered straight to your email. Yum!

A Milwaukee staple, Maria’s Pizza has been delighting diners with delicious pies in a fun, quirky setting since 1957.
Joe Frost/Google
In 1971, a 2nd Maria’s opened, and by 1993, the two eateries were consolidated into one, which is the current location on Forest Home Avenue.
Ron Zalewski/Google
Both restaurants were opened by Maria Traxel. Sticking to her roots, Traxel, who was 100% Italian, wanted to open a spaghetti restaurant, but her customers wanted pizza – and the rest is history.
Timothy K/Google
After one bite, you’ll quickly understand why patrons have fallen in love with Maria’s signature pies.
Z Zylka/Google
Not only delicious, the pies at Maria’s are unlike any other in the city.
Maria’s Pizza/Facebook
The pizza’s hallmark is a perfectly thin crust that’s nice and crispy…at first. Once the cheese and toppings soak into the crust, it softens up a bit, enabling it to be folded over or even rolled up like a burrito.
Jennie Steil/Google

Related Stories

Some Of Wisconsin's Best Pizza Is Served Up Daily At This Small Town Restaurant

Some Of Wisconsin's Best Pizza Is Served Up Daily At This Small Town Restaurant

 Wisconsin's First Italian Restaurant Has Literally Been Around Forever

Wisconsin's First Italian Restaurant Has Literally Been Around Forever

 You’ve Never Tasted Pizza Quite Like The Pies Made At Rustique Pizzeria In Wisconsin

You’ve Never Tasted Pizza Quite Like The Pies Made At Rustique Pizzeria In Wisconsin
Keeping things simple, the pizza comes in just two sizes: a 14” round pie or an 18” rectangle pie. Regardless of which size you order, it’ll be served on a baking sheet that can barely contain it.
Bill Hutchinson/Google
The topping selection isn’t huge, either. However, it includes all the classics, such as pepperoni, sausage, mushrooms, green peppers, black olives, and onions.
Mary Baker/Google
Signature pies are just one of Maria’s mainstay features, though.
Bill Ostrowski/Google
Another trademark is its quirky décor, which includes a mix of over-the-top holiday decorations, vintage signs, and religious paint-by-number artwork.
James Semanko/Google
And just like when it first opened, Maria’s is still owned and operated by members of the Traxel family.
Christin L/Google
The classic features don’t end there, though. Since opening, Maria’s has only accepted one method of payment – cash – so make sure to stop by the ATM before your visit.
r Plazas/Google

Hours are 3 p.m. until 7 p.m. Wednesday-Sunday. For more information, call Maria’s Pizza at (414) 543-4606. You can also visit the Maria’s Pizza Facebook page.

So, did you know about this legendary pizzeria? Ever visited? If so, how was it? Tell us in the comments section.

Looking for other places to satisfy your pizza craving? Click here.

OnlyInYourState may earn compensation through affiliate links in this article. As an Amazon Associate, we earn from qualifying purchases.

Related Articles

Explore Wisconsin

Featured Addresses
5025 W Forest Home Ave, Milwaukee, WI 53219, USA