At Black Otter Supper Club in Wisconsin, it’s always prime (rib) time! A must-visit for carnivores, the eatery is the home of the 160-ounce Extreme Cut Prime Rib. In addition to giant prime ribs, the menu includes a variety of other steaks as well as seafood, pork, and chicken. Oh, and did we mention there’s a soup and salad bar? Take a look:

Worth every mile it takes to get to, the Black Otter Supper Club is located in the small town of Hortonville.
Heather V/TripAdvisor
Open since 1972, the eatery has had plenty of time to perfect its specialty – prime rib. But not just any prime rib…
pcamy07/TripAdvisor
...Black Otter Supper Club is known for serving up gigantic prime ribs.
Jack Jackson/Google
So, just how gigantic are we talking about? Well, the largest is the Extreme Cut Prime Rib, which is a whopping 160 ounces!
Mark Parker/Google
There’s also the Super Cut Prime Rib, which at 116 ounces, is the second largest prime rib on the menu.
JoAnn E/TripAdvisor
Both the Extreme Cut and Super Cut Prime Ribs are part of food challenges, which require that you finish off the entire steak all by yourself.
JenPhotoGirl/TripAdvisor

Related Stories

Some Of Wisconsin's Best Steaks Are Served At Farmstead, A 150-Year-Old Farmhouse Turned Restaurant

Some Of Wisconsin's Best Steaks Are Served At Farmstead, A 150-Year-Old Farmhouse Turned Restaurant

 Schwarz's Supper Club In Wisconsin Serves Up Some Of The Biggest Steaks In The State      

Schwarz's Supper Club In Wisconsin Serves Up Some Of The Biggest Steaks In The State      

 These 7 Wisconsin Coast Seafood Restaurants Are Worth A Visit From Any Part Of The State

These 7 Wisconsin Coast Seafood Restaurants Are Worth A Visit From Any Part Of The State
Anyone who finishes the Extreme Cut will get a $20 gift certificate, photo on the “wall of fame,” and a t-shirt. And those who are able to scarf down the Super Cut will get a t-shirt and picture on the “wall of fame.”
Eduardo G. Arana/Google
Not all the prime ribs are abnormally large, though. The menu also includes the 32-ounce Queen Cut and the 72-ounce King Cut. And while the prime ribs vary in size, they’re all slow-roasted for several hours and served with au jus.
red green/Google
Though one of the most popular options, prime rib isn’t the only steak you’ll find on the menu. The tasty selection also includes tenderloin, Black Angus rib-eye, and Porterhouse.
Sheila W/TripAdvisor
No matter which steak you order, it’ll come with the potato of your choice along with limitless trips to the soup and salad bar, which is brimming with hot soups and fresh fixings.
Michael Nellis/Google
Of course, you don’t have to eat steak at all. The expansive menu features a variety of seafood, pork, chicken, and more.
Tim Long/Google
It may be the Black Otter Supper Club's unique appearance that initially attracts diners, but it's without a doubt the massive prime ribs and other tasty dishes that keep them coming back!
Paul K/TripAdvisor

Black Otter Supper Club in Wisconsin is typically open Tuesday-Thursday and on Sundays, from 4 p.m. – 8:30 p.m., and Friday-Saturday, from 4 p.m. – 10 p.m. For the latest information, call (920) 779-6975. You can also visit the restaurant’s website or Facebook page.

Have you ever been to this incredible supper club in Wisconsin? Did you attempt the giant prime rib challenge? Share your thoughts and experiences with us in the comments below! And if you know another epic eatery in America’s Dairyland, nominate it for a chance to be featured.

For more tasty eats, check out this sassy small town BBQ restaurant in Wisconsin.

OnlyInYourState may earn compensation through affiliate links in this article. As an Amazon Associate, we earn from qualifying purchases.

More to Explore

Black Otter Supper Club in Wisconsin

Elisa Regulski | September 23, 2020

Where can I find the best prime rib in Wisconsin?

Craving some delicious prime rib? Well, you can eat to your heart’s content at Copper Dock in Hubertus. This all-you-can-eat restaurant will certainly spark your appetite. Their flavorful meats and tasty side dishes will thoroughly satisfy your hunger cravings. Come see why some think this is the best place to get prime rib in Wisconsin!

What are the best supper clubs in Wisconsin?

Supper Clubs are Wisconsin staples. There’s something so amazing about lounging in a comfortable booth while devouring a delicious meal. And with an old fashioned in hand, life couldn’t get sweeter. If you need some ideas of where to go on your next dining adventure, check out our list of the best small town supper clubs in Wisconsin. You’ll love each and every place on this list.

What are the best steakhouses in Wisconsin?

If you’re looking for one of the most charming, out-of-the-way steakhouses in Wisconsin, head to Bistro 63 in Barronett. This classy restaurant serves magnificent meals in a gorgeous setting. You’ll love their amazing Steak Oscar dish. If you really want to get fancy, you can even top your steak with fresh seafood like perfectly-seasoned scallops and shrimp. If you yearn for a taste of days gone by, visit Tornado Steak House in Madison. This retro eatery was named the best steakhouse in Wisconsin, and it’s easy so see why. The nostalgic atmosphere and superb meals create a one-of-a-kind experience you can’t get anywhere else.

Related Articles

Explore Wisconsin

Featured Addresses
503 S Nash St, Hortonville, WI 54944, USA