Autumn’s arrival also brings with it some of the season’s most delicious treats, from freshly-pressed apple cider slushies to creamy pumpkin ice cream. If we don’t treat ourselves during the fall, we’ll have to wait an entire year for the delightful goodies to reappear on menus. These six places serve some of the most delicious pumpkin ice cream in Pennsylvania.

1. Moo Hope Ice Cream – New Hope
Trip Advisor/Mitch Phyllis65
Trip Advisor/Mitch Phyllis65
Can you think of a better place to treat yourself to a pumpkin ice cream treat than Moo Hope Ice Cream? The family-run ice cream shop serves some of the best pumpkin ice cream around. Want to spice things up a bit? Order the pumpkin chip ice cream. (All ice cream is made right at the shop.)
2. Mr. G’s Ice Cream – Gettysburg
Facebook/Mr. G’s
Facebook/Mr. G’s
Treat yourself to homemade pumpkin ice cream in a charming, historic setting. Now that fall has arrived, the pumpkin ice cream has returned to Mr. G’s Ice Cream. You can also order other popular goodies such as milkshakes, sundaes, and even soft serve ice cream.
3. Leo’s Homemade Ice Cream – Carlisle
Facebook/Leo’s Homemade Ice Cream
Facebook/Leo’s Homemade Ice Cream
You have a long list of scrumptious ice cream flavors from which to choose at Leo’s Homemade Ice Cream. All of the ice cream is, of course, homemade, promising the deliciousness that comes from homemade. Treat yourself to a cup or a cone of pumpkin ice cream now that autumn’s here.

Related Stories

The Pennsylvania Bakery Makes Some Of The State's Best Homemade Gobs

The Pennsylvania Bakery Makes Some Of The State's Best Homemade Gobs

 Pennsylvania's Oldest Candy Shop, Shane Confectionery, Has Been Around Since 1863 And It's Not Hard To See Why

Pennsylvania's Oldest Candy Shop, Shane Confectionery, Has Been Around Since 1863 And It's Not Hard To See Why

 Sample Treats From The Past At The Peppermint Stick Candy Store In Pennsylvania

Sample Treats From The Past At The Peppermint Stick Candy Store In Pennsylvania
4. Shady Brook Farm – Yardley
Facebook/Shady Brook Farm
Facebook/Shady Brook Farm
Celebrate the season with a day of fun fall festivities at Shady Brook Farm. The highlight of your visit will likely be, of course, the delicious homemade pumpkin ice cream. How do you prefer it – in a cup or in a cone? Shady Brook Farm’s fall festival also features a pumpkin patch, a corn maze, and more.
5. Chester Springs Creamery at Milky Way Farms – Chester Springs
Facebook/Chester Springs Creamery
Facebook/Chester Springs Creamery
Polly’s Pumpkin Ice Cream has returned to Chester Springs Creamery for the fall season. Milky Way Farms also features a Fall Harvest, so you can enjoy a full menu of activities, including pick your own pumpkins. You can escape a corn maze, too.
6. Kerber’s Dairy – Irwin
Facebook/Kerber’s Dairy
Facebook/Kerber’s Dairy
You have several scrumptious choices when it comes to pumpkin ice cream at Kerber’s Dairy. Try the traditional pumpkin or the pumpkin pecan. But, before you enjoy ice cream, visit during Pumpkin Days. Go on a hayride to the pumpkin patch. Stock up on Halloween decorations, and watch the kids on the playground.

What are your favorite places to get the best pumpkin ice cream in Pennsylvania? Join the conversation in the comments! If you love a good apple cider donut, visit one of these six spots in PA. Click here to read more.

OnlyInYourState may earn compensation through affiliate links in this article. As an Amazon Associate, we earn from qualifying purchases.

Related Articles

Explore Pennsylvania

Featured Addresses
22 S Main St, New Hope, PA 18938, USA
404 Baltimore St, Gettysburg, PA 17325, USA
Stony Hill Rd, Yardley, PA, USA
816 W High St, Carlisle, PA 17015, USA
521 E Uwchlan Ave, Chester Springs, PA 19425, USA
Kerber's Dairy, 1856 Guffey Rd, Irwin, PA 15642, USA