What’s the first thing that comes to mind when you hear Prantl’s Bakery? If you’re like most Pittsburghers, you probably immediately think of the charming bakery’s burnt almond torte, named Pennsylvania’s best cake by The Food Network. Now, however, that famously delicious cake has a little bit of competition: The thumbprint cookie. That’s right. Prantl’s Bakery in Pittsburgh makes thumbprint cookies, using the original recipe, in more than 60 sensational flavors.

Sink your teeth into a classic thumbprint cookie at Prantl's Bakery and you just might find yourself overcome by nostalgia.
Trip Advisor/Mehmet
A Pittsburgh original, thumbprints first appeared in the city in 1980, made by Kevin Ulrich of Kaufmann's Arcade Bakery. And, for decades, Pittsburghers frequented the Arcade Bakery to stock up on their favorite thumbprint cookies.
Four Square/Angela P.
Then, Kaufmann's - and with it Arcade Bakery - permanently closed its doors, leaving the famed thumbprints without a home.
Facebook/Prantl’s Bakery
But, that all changed in 2017 when Ulrich joined Prantl's Bakery to make the famous thumbprint cookies, now available in more than 60 flavors.
Facebook/Prantl’s Bakery
In fact, next time you're craving a classic thumbprint, just stop by Prantl's locations in Shadyside, Market Square, or Greensburg.
Facebook/Prantl’s Bakery

Related Stories

The Milkshakes From This Marvelous Pittsburgh Milkshake Shop Are Almost Too Wonderful To Be Real

The Milkshakes From This Marvelous Pittsburgh Milkshake Shop Are Almost Too Wonderful To Be Real

 Step Into Spring With A Homemade Ice Cream Treat At This Classic Ice Cream Shop Near Pittsburgh

Step Into Spring With A Homemade Ice Cream Treat At This Classic Ice Cream Shop Near Pittsburgh

 The Retro Ice Cream Parlor In Pittsburgh That Serves Scrumptious Homemade Ice Cream

The Retro Ice Cream Parlor In Pittsburgh That Serves Scrumptious Homemade Ice Cream
There, you'll discover an assortment of tantalizing flavors from classic chocolate and vanilla to peanut butter and s'mores.
Prantl’s Bakery
Or, go for something a little bolder like the strawberry cheesecake, mint chocolate chip, or the pumpkin.
Trip Advisor/management
Of course, you can't stop at Prantl's without grabbing a burnt almond torte cake for the road. Or, try other goodies, such as junior pastries, cookies, and donuts.
Trip Advisor/management
Indulge in a scrumptious thumbprint cookie and other goodies at Prantl's Bakery, open in Shadyside Sunday and Monday from 9 a.m. to 4 p.m. and Tuesday through Saturday from 7:30 a.m. to 6 p.m.
Facebook/Prantl’s Bakery
Prantl's Bakery is located in Shadyside at 5525 Walnut St., Pittsburgh, PA 15232. Or, visit the Market Square or Greensburg locations.
Trip Advisor/paxa
Click here for the official website of Prantl's Bakery. Or, go here for Facebook.

Have you had the thumbprint cookies at Prantl’s Bakery in Pittsburgh? What kind are your favorite? Let us know in the comments! And, if you love chocolate chip cookies just like grandma used to make, stop by Nancy B’s. Click here to read more.

OnlyInYourState may earn compensation through affiliate links in this article. As an Amazon Associate, we earn from qualifying purchases.

Related Articles