Editor’s Note: Good ‘N Plenty is permanently closed.

Sit down for a leisurely meal without having to spend hours in a hot kitchen. Pass the bowls of your favorite homemade dishes – mashed potatoes, sweet corn, and buttered noodles, for example – to one another and add generous portions to your dinner plate. Experience an old-fashioned family meal at this charming Amish restaurant in Pennsylvania.

Good 'N Plenty Restaurant has been a family favorite of Pennsylvanians since 1969, earning accolades as the "Best Local PA Dutch Restaurant" for 17 years running.
Yelp/Sandi B.
Housed in a quaint farmhouse built in 1871, the charming Good 'N Plenty Restaurant offers both family style dining and menu dining.
Yelp/Joy G.
Feel as though you're at a friend's home when you walk into the authentic Amish restaurant adorned with charming artwork and...
Yelp/Agnes A.
Decorated with traditional wooden tables covered by checkered tablecloths.
Yelp/Arlene L.
Enjoy the buzz of conversation in the family-style dining room as you peruse the dishes on the menu, including homemade meatloaf, baked chicken pie, roast beef, roast turkey, and steamed fish.
Facebook/Good ‘N Plenty Restaurant

Related Stories

The Outdoor Cafe In Pennsylvania That Is The Prettiest Place To Enjoy A Warm Afternoon

The Outdoor Cafe In Pennsylvania That Is The Prettiest Place To Enjoy A Warm Afternoon

 Explore Thousands Of Acres Of Trails, Flora, and Fauna At Pennsylvania's Otherworldly Cherry Valley National Wildlife Refuge

Explore Thousands Of Acres Of Trails, Flora, and Fauna At Pennsylvania's Otherworldly Cherry Valley National Wildlife Refuge

 We Experienced A Delicious, Over-The-Top Chocolate Feast In Hershey, Pennsylvania

We Experienced A Delicious, Over-The-Top Chocolate Feast In Hershey, Pennsylvania
Or, choose four side orders - whipped potatoes, chow chow, pepper cabbage, and corn nuggets, to name a few - to create your own scrumptious meal.
Yelp/Good ‘N Plenty Restaurant
Indulge in a traditional family-style meal, the most popular dining choice at Good 'N Plenty, where you can pass the dishes around just like at the dinner table at home.
Yelp/Good ‘N Plenty Restaurant
Family-style dishes include crispy fried chicken, chow chow, applesauce, cottage cheese, freshly baked white or wheat bread, brown buttered noodles, sweet corn, and whipped potatoes.
Yelp/Daniel Z.
Save room for mouthwatering dessert: Homemade pudding, cheesecake, pie, shoofly pie, or ice cream. Desserts are made fresh at the restaurant's bakery.
Yelp/Good ‘N Plenty Restaurant
Browse the quaint gift shop for a souvenir, a unique handmade gift, or to stock up on such delectable goodies as apple butter, chow chow, and shoofly pie from the on-site bakery.
Yelp/Dan R.
Dine at Good 'N Plenty Restaurant for a home-cooked meal you'll never forget.
Facebook/Good ‘N Plenty Restaurant

Address:

Good ‘N Plenty Restaurant
150 Eastbrook Road
Smoketown, PA 17576
717-394-7111
Click here for more information.

A charming Amish restaurant in Pennsylvania, Good ‘N Plenty is one among many delightful hometown restaurants that promise a traditional home-cooked meal.

Have you ever eaten at this charming restaurant? If so, what’s your favorite dish on the menu? Share your thoughts with us in the comments below! And if you know another delicious country restaurant in Pennsylvania, nominate it for a chance to be featured.

OnlyInYourState may earn compensation through affiliate links in this article. As an Amazon Associate, we earn from qualifying purchases.

More to Explore

Amish restaurant in Pennsylvania

Elisa Regulski | June 22, 2020

What are the best Amish restaurants in Pennsylvania?

Good ‘N Plenty Restaurant in Pennsylvania isn’t the only place you can get delicious Amish food. Katie's Kitchen, located in Strasburg, is also known for their magnificent dishes. Here, you can devour delicious meatloaf and roasted chicken. Pair this with some mashed potatoes and gravy, and you have the recipe for a perfect meal. Be sure to save room for dessert! Their apple dumplings are absolutely incredible. For more excellent Amish meals, visit Dutch Eating Place in Philadelphia. Their chicken corn soup and hot roast beef can’t be beat.

What are the most charming restaurants in Pennsylvania?

If you’re looking for charming restaurants in Pennsylvania, you’re in luck. There are so many delightful eateries in the state. For some tasty country eats in a welcoming setting, visit Clifford’s Restaurant in Evans City. Their juicy pork chops and chicken marsala are nothing short of amazing. If you loved this place, you should also check out Whip Tavern in Coatesville. This authentic English pub serves all of the classics: fish and chips, bangers and mash, and delicious beer. Slide up to the bar and enjoy a delectable meal.

What is Amish food? 

At most Amish restaurants, you’ll find comfort food classics like fried chicken, meat loaf, and mashed potatoes. But that’s not all the Amish are known for. Be sure to try some scrumptious scrapple and Dutch cabbage rolls. For dessert, enjoy classic dishes like shoofly pie and apple dumplings. There are so many fantastic Amish bakeries in Pennsylvania as well. These lovely places boast incredible pastries, breads, and sweet treats.

Related Articles

Featured Addresses
150 Eastbrook Rd, Smoketown, PA 17576, USA