Out in the old Wild West, one would expect to find remnants of scuffles between law enforcement and outlaws. In Cleveland, however? Such a thing would be unheard of… one would think. Believe it or not, there’s one place in Cleveland with Prohibition-era bullet holes, and some were left by one of the most famous crime fighters to ever live in The Land. Prepare to travel through time, because the historic 1872 Market Tavern building in Cleveland has a story to tell. If only walls could talk…

Great Lakes Brewing Company, a coveted Cleveland beer brand, has a charming microbrewery on Market Avenue.
Great Lakes Brewing Company/Google Images
The Brewpub opened in 1988 and quickly became a local landmark. The building it opened in is full of history, boasting a past with one of Ohio City's first small businesses. You can tour the Brewpub to discover how the past and present are connected in this amazing place. The building underwent renovations in 2020, which emphasized its historic elements. As cozy and as welcoming as ever before, this destination is a cool spot to unwind in Ohio City.
You can often find some of their most iconic beers on tap...
Mike/Google Images
Wondering what's on tap right now? You can check on their website for current offerings at this location.
...Which pair perfectly with their menu of New American and tavern-style offerings.
Kent Miller/Google Images
Their menu is modest but mighty. Wings, pretzels and beer cheese, pierogies, brats, and other delicacies delight diners with flavor that's as warm and as welcoming as a hug.
The bar is super welcoming and — wait... are those bullet holes on the wall?!
Eric Price/Google Images
The bullet holes are often a topic of conversation among visitors. It's not exactly something one would expect to see hiding in plain sight, and yet... there they are.

Related Stories

12 Photos Showcasing The Era Of Cleveland's Department Store Empire

12 Photos Showcasing The Era Of Cleveland's Department Store Empire

 Locals Wonder If Infamous Gangster Al Capone Had Ties To Cleveland's Little Italy

Locals Wonder If Infamous Gangster Al Capone Had Ties To Cleveland's Little Italy

 Here’s The Story Behind The Massive Soldiers' and Sailors' Monument In Cleveland

Here’s The Story Behind The Massive Soldiers' and Sailors' Monument In Cleveland
Why, yes. Yes, they are. This bar opened in 1988, but it has a story that begins much, much earlier.
Great Lakes Brewing Company/Facebook
The massive building once housed the Herrman-McLean Feed and Seed Co., which surely brought locals from more rural regions into town. The building also housed the old Market Tavern at one time, which operated for years before and after Prohibition. One can't think of Prohibition without recalling the efforts of Prohibition agent Eliot Ness, the man often credited with taking down Al Capone. While many don't know what happened to Ness after Capone's reign of terror ended, locals know that he ended up in Cleveland... and his story got a little bit ironic when he discovered his love of liquor.
While some believe that the bullet holes may be attributed to Eliot Ness himself, that is up for debate.
Great Lakes Brewing Company/Facebook
Eliot Ness, whose final resting place is Lake View Cemetery in Cleveland, served as Cleveland's Safety Director from 1935 until the early 1940s. He had a... reputation, we'll say, in Cleveland. In addition to serving during the infamous Torso Murders, Ness was quite a social drinker. He did manage to reduce traffic-related fatalities during his tenure, which helped Cleveland shake its reputation as one of the most dangerous places to drive in the nation. Ironically, he caused an accident while drunk driving that looked suspiciously like a hit and run, and it caused many locals to lose faith in him. He left the city and returned years later to run for mayor, but was unsuccessful.
While Ness never carried a gun, the bullet holes may still tie back to the era during which he served the city... and may even be directly tied to him.
Great Lakes Brewing Company/Facebook
Ness may not have fired the gun that permanently marked the walls at this venue, but it's possible he drank here on occasion. Some of the bullet holes are filled in on the 1901 bar, but one is proudly marked with a comical "Bang!" flag. The old bar is worth swinging by and checking out, regardless of who put the bullet holes in the wall. It's original to the building, and it was only removed during Prohibition (and, during that era, it was really only moved upstairs and out of sight). Try an Eliot Ness Amber Lager to tie the experience together... it's a true Cleveland favorite.
Swing by the Brewpub for the history, but stay for the food and drinks. Bring some friends, because dining here is oodles of fun!
Great Lakes Brewing Company/Google Images
Point out the bullet holes to your friends and tell them about the history recounted here to impress them. They just might have their own theories about the history of this old building!
History abounds at the Great Lakes Brewing Company.
Jeffrey: Dad of three boys/Google Images
Visit the Brewpub at 2516 Market Ave., Cleveland, Ohio 44113.

There’s so much to love about the historic 1872 Market Tavern building, from the ambiance to the ever-flowing beverages. What do you think… will you be paying this local landmark a visit?

Looking for more cool breweries to visit? Check out our Cleveland brewery trail to keep the libations going.

OnlyInYourState may earn compensation through affiliate links in this article. As an Amazon Associate, we earn from qualifying purchases.

Related Articles

Featured Addresses
2516 Market Ave, Cleveland, OH 44113, USA