Sometimes, you can find great food tucked away in unexpected places. It’s often easy to get trapped in the old routines, visiting the same eateries over and over. If you find yourself stuck at the same spots, break up the monotony with a visit to one of the many hidden gem restaurants in New York. One of our favorites is tucked away in the Catskills in the little hamlet of Big Indian. It’s far from what you might consider a typical foodie town, but the meals here could compete with just about any in the state. The Peekamoose Restaurant and Tap Room has been delighting New Yorkers since it opened in 2003.

Big Indian is in Big Indian Wilderness, a massive preserve that houses uninterrupted virgin forest in the Catskills. This is a great place for a day trip or weekend adventure.
Steve Brown/Google Maps
There's so many trails in this area, so get out and explore.
After you've hiked the day away, settle down for a great meal at the Peekamoose Restaurant. They're open for dinner in the evenings and serve a variety of meals, including vegetarian and gluten-free options.
Peekamoose Restaurant/Google Maps
The rustic decor is a perfect match for the beautifully untamed surroundings outside. There's outdoor dining (weather permitting), but the interior is just as beautiful.
David Packer/Google Maps

Related Stories

The Tiny Restaurant That Serves The Arguably Best Oysters In All Of New York

The Tiny Restaurant That Serves The Arguably Best Oysters In All Of New York

 A Secret Door Will Take You To An Underground Restaurant In New York That's Beneath A Hindu Temple

A Secret Door Will Take You To An Underground Restaurant In New York That's Beneath A Hindu Temple

 Funk n' Waffles In New York Is A No-Fuss Hideaway With The Best Waffles

Funk n' Waffles In New York Is A No-Fuss Hideaway With The Best Waffles
And the food manages to be just as good-looking! This farm-to-table spot sells locally-sourced food that is the absolute highest of quality.
Peekamoose Restaurant/Google Maps
Since the menu changes seasonally depending on availability, each trip is a new experience. It's all deliciously fresh and procured from the surrounding areas.
R Lawson/Google Maps
The building was converted from an old farmhouse. The decorations look like something out of a fairy tale woodland and it really adds to the atmosphere.
Marion NYC/Google Maps
With such a gorgeous setting and incredible food, you really can't go wrong here.
Peekamoose Restaurant/Google Maps

For more information, including a current menu, check out Peekamoose Restaurant’s website.

Have you eaten at this hidden gem restaurant in New York? Share your experiences in the comments!

OnlyInYourState may earn compensation through affiliate links in this article. As an Amazon Associate, we earn from qualifying purchases.

Related Articles

Explore New York

Featured Addresses
Peekamoose Restaurant, 8373 NY-28, Big Indian, NY 12410, USA