Editor’s Note: Since the publication of this article, El Rincon Mexicano has permanently closed.

It’s no secret that many of our larger cities in New York have great restaurants. New York City, Buffalo, Albany, Rochester: all are top foodie destinations in one way or another. Therefore, you maybe wouldn’t expect some of the best Mexican food in New York to be hiding in… Sodus? This rural village is small: the population is under 2,000. It’s home to El Rincon Mexicano, a hidden gem restaurant in New York that doesn’t look like much, but serves up delicious, fresh food. The food here is every bit as good as that you’d find in larger towns.

The location is about 45 minutes east of Rochester. It was first opened in 1991 to serve migrant workers in the area who were missing home. Today, it's still owned by the same family that originally opened it.
Vinu Thomas/Google Maps
The decor is colorful and festive, like that of many Mexican restaurants.
Aaron Stuckey/Google Maps
While some of the dishes have been slightly Americanized, overall, most of the food is quite authentic. This is undoubtedly one of the best Mexican restaurants in New York.
Jon Dubner/Google Maps

Related Stories

Sample Unlimited Tacos At The Upcoming Hudson Valley Taco Fest In New York

Sample Unlimited Tacos At The Upcoming Hudson Valley Taco Fest In New York

 For Authentic Japanese Soba That Will Rock Your World, Head To Sobaya In New York

For Authentic Japanese Soba That Will Rock Your World, Head To Sobaya In New York

 The One Small Neighborhood In New York With Delicious Chinese Food On Every Corner

The One Small Neighborhood In New York With Delicious Chinese Food On Every Corner
All of the food here is fresh and locally-sourced whenever possible. The dishes are so colorful and beautifully presented.
El Rincon Mexicano
There can sometimes be a little bit of a wait, but that's simply because everything is made fresh to order. Trust us, it's definitely worth having to hold out for!
The fresh salsa is incredible, and if you prefer guacamole, theirs is rich and tasty.
El Rincon Mexicano
The portions are huge. Everything is so delicious that it might be difficult to rein in your appetite, but many dishes here are large enough to bring home some leftovers.
El Rincon Mexicano/Google Maps
It's a bit of a hike to get here from the areas you'd typically expect to find great restaurants in New York. This rural spot so delicious and a great option for anyone looking for flavor in an unexpected location!
El Rincon Mexicano/Google Maps

For more information about this tasty Mexican restaurant in New York, check out its website.

OnlyInYourState may earn compensation through affiliate links in this article. As an Amazon Associate, we earn from qualifying purchases.

Related Articles

Explore New York

Featured Addresses
El Rincon Mexicano, 6974 Ridge Rd, Sodus, NY 14551, USA