Ice cream is often associated with the summer season, but here in Buffalo, we tend to have a sweet tooth that gives us cravings all year long. Right near Ellicott Creek and Glenn Park, there’s a charming ice cream shop that has quite a long history with the Queen City and Western New York. Creating homemade sweets and treats that’ll be the ultimate cherry on top of your day, keep reading if you’re ready to be craving dessert by the time you’re done with this article!

Sweet Jenny's Ice Cream has been satisfying Buffalonians since 1985, but it was only a few years ago that they moved into their current location - a restored water mill that'll take you back to the good old days.
Sweet Jenny's - Buffalo - NY/Facebook
You'll feel right at home as soon as you walk into the beautiful space, and before your eyes can even digest what you're seeing, your heart will fall in love with the delicious aroma that fills the air here.
Sweet Jenny's - Buffalo - NY/Facebook
On one side of the store, you'll find a huge variety of hand-dipped chocolates on display and ready to make your stomach rumble.
Sweet Jenny's - Buffalo - NY/Facebook
Made right in the store, Sweet Jenny's treats include everything from orange chocolate and sponge candy to classics like french silks and chocolate laced popcorn. Tasty!
Sweet Jenny's - Buffalo - NY/Facebook
The chocolate here alone is enough to keep you occupied for a lengthy amount of time, but you'll also find penny candies and even our favorite Crystal Beach suckers here too.
Sweet Jenny's - Buffalo - NY/Facebook

Related Stories

The Gigantic Candy Store Near Buffalo You’ll Want To Visit Over And Over Again

The Gigantic Candy Store Near Buffalo You’ll Want To Visit Over And Over Again

 The Elm Street Bakery Near Buffalo Is One Of The Best On Earth

The Elm Street Bakery Near Buffalo Is One Of The Best On Earth

 You Need To Visit Mazurek's, The One Remaining Old-Time Polish Bakery In All Of Buffalo

You Need To Visit Mazurek's, The One Remaining Old-Time Polish Bakery In All Of Buffalo
Those who explore upstairs will find an entire comic store hidden away, with quite a few vintage video games that come as a delightful surprise.
Brittany Maxwell/Google
But let's talk about the heart of Sweet Jenny's: the ice cream.
Sweet Jenny's Ice Cream/TripAdvisor
Sweet Jenny's makes their own amazing waffle cones and feature about 10 flavors that are available in the shop at all times.
Sweet Jenny's - Buffalo - NY/Facebook
You'll also find other rotating flavors that are featured regularly and will make you appreciate that this ice cream shop is open all year long.
Sweet Jenny's - Buffalo - NY/Facebook
Combining history with mouthwatering treats, Sweet Jenny's is the perfect spot to enjoy ice cream all throughout the year.
Rita M/TripAdvisor
When it comes to pleasing your sweet tooth, Sweet Jenny's knows exactly how to get the job done. At Sweet Jenny's you can order things like ice cream pies and sponge candy, as well as head upstairs to pick out a comic and play some video games. Could it get any better than this?

Now located inside the restored Williamsville Water Mill, Sweet Jenny's has never been sweeter. To find out more about this ice cream shop and everything else that they carry, check out their website here.

Sweet Jenny’s is located at 56 East Spring St., Buffalo NY 14221 and is open Monday through Thursday from 10 a.m. to 8:30 p.m., Friday and Saturday from 10 a.m. to 9 p.m., and Sundays from 11 a.m. to 8 p.m.

What’s the best thing that you’ve ever tasted at Sweet Jenny’s? For more sweet spots around the Queen City, check out how This Underrated Chocolate Shop Near Buffalo Has Some Of The Best Sweets Around!

OnlyInYourState may earn compensation through affiliate links in this article. As an Amazon Associate, we earn from qualifying purchases.

Related Articles