Frozen custard has been served in America for over 100 years, and there’s definitely something nostalgic about enjoying this delicious treat. If you drive a mere 25 miles north of Buffalo, you’ll find Hibbard’s Original Frozen Custard in Lewistown, which has been serving amazing frozen custard since 1939.

You'll find Hibbard's at 105 Portage Road in Lewistown.
saveroom4dessert / TripAdvisor
They've been family owned and operated since their 1939 beginnings. Harold Hibbard Sr. fell in love with frozen custard as soon as he tried it, and the custard shop opened a few years later.
The frozen custard is handmade using the original recipe.
Hibbard's

Related Stories

The Underrated Chocolate Shop Near Buffalo That Has Some Of The Best Sweets Around

The Underrated Chocolate Shop Near Buffalo That Has Some Of The Best Sweets Around

 There's So Much More To This Unique Bakery In Buffalo Than Meets The Eye

There's So Much More To This Unique Bakery In Buffalo Than Meets The Eye

 Buffalonians Have Spoken And This Is The Absolute Favorite Donut Shop In The City

Buffalonians Have Spoken And This Is The Absolute Favorite Donut Shop In The City
There's a reason this custard is so irresistible.
Madmaggie42 / TripAdvisor
In the design of the custard machine, less air gets pumped into the custard, leaving a creamier and richer treat than ice cream.
Along with a daily rotating flavor menu, you'll find plenty of creative flavors available by the pint.
Trev/Foursquare
The milkshakes and custard sundaes are to die for.
Hibbard's Original Custard is open daily from 11 a.m. - 10 p.m., so you'll have plenty of time to try it.
Chuck T/Foursquare
There's a reason this place is thriving nearly a century after opening.

Summer is the perfect time to enjoy a cool frozen treat. Check out our Buffalo ice cream trail.

OnlyInYourState may earn compensation through affiliate links in this article. As an Amazon Associate, we earn from qualifying purchases.

Related Articles