8 Food Faux-Pas A Buffalonian Should Never, Ever Commit

As New Yorkers, we take our food selections and pairings very seriously, and we’re not afraid to voice our concern (or disgust) if you do things differently. Perhaps nowhere in the state is this as true as when you’re dining in Buffalo. If you’re new around here and want to fit in, consider this your guide to dining like a New Yorker – an unofficial rulebook, if you will. If you’re strolling through town and have a hankering for some authentic Buffalo, New York, foods, committing these unforgivable food faux-pas in Buffalo is a sure way to get pinned as a tourist!

stu_spivack/Flickr

Do not – I repeat – DO NOT do this. This is the ultimate Buffalo food faux-pas. Under no circumstance should your wings be dipped in anything other than bleu cheese.

Jo Zimny/Flickr

Speaking of dipping... the only chip dip that passes the Buffalo test is Bison Dip. End of story.

Advertisement

Scott Wilcoxson/Flickr

No other type of hot dog grills up better than a Sahlens, and Buffalonians are very loyal to these summertime favorites. If you're invited to a backyard BBQ in Buffalo, be warned: bringing any other brand will leave you mocked and ridiculed (and probably left without an invitation for the next gathering).

Advertisement

Bar Bill Tavern/Facebook

It's called beef on weck for a reason. The kimmelweck roll is what makes this classic Buffalo sandwich. Ordering it on a normal roll - or worse, scraping the toppings off of the kimmelweck - is a serious food faux-pas in Western New York.

Related Stories

9 Easy Hikes To Add To Your Outdoor Bucket List In Buffalo

12 Unforgettable Buffalo Day Trips, One For Each Month Of The Year

8 Gorgeous Lakes To Visit Around Buffalo This Summer

Marcus Veytia/GoogleReviews

Morning coffee runs in Buffalo always start with Timmy Ho's, and you'll get bonus points at any workplace if you show up with a pack of assorted Tim Bits.

Original Pizza Logs/Facebook

Pizza logs were created right here in Western New York, and no one does it better! Attempting to pass the microwaveable, imitation grocery store pizza logs off as the real deal is a serious no-no in Buffalo.

ChristinaEatsBrains/Flickr

Super Mighty > anything on Taco Bell's menu. Mighty Taco is a Buffalo staple, and trying to defend Taco Bell's offerings is another major food faux-pas. (Side note: Can you say Mighty Taco without getting their jingle stuck in your head? I can't.)

La Nova Pizzeria/Facebook

There's New York style pizza, and then there's BUFFALO, NEW YORK style pizza. True Buffalonians will always, always choose the latter.

Tell us: What are the worst food atrocities that you’ve witnessed in Buffalo? And more importantly, are you still friends with the person who committed them? Drop a comment below! We’d also love to know if there are any others you would add to the list.

Food rules aside, Buffalo, New York dining is pretty spectacular – in fact, the city as a whole has a ton of things to do, even if you’ve lived here awhile. But if you’re looking for a new hangout, we’ve rounded up a whole list of unique dining experiences for you to try! (Just please keep the above food faux-pas in Buffalo in mind while you eat.)

These 10 Unique Restaurants In Buffalo Will Give You An Unforgettable Dining Experience