Here in the Queen City, it’s been proven time and time again that some of our most beloved restaurants are ones that you may not usually stop and look twice at. Disguised by an exterior that still showcases the 25 years that this eatery was actually an auto repair show, we wouldn’t blame you if you passed by this amazing dining destination without realizing it even was one. Located over on the tasty Hertel Avenue, find out why this one unassuming restaurant has some of the best food you’ll ever taste.

After 25 years in the auto repair business, the Riniolo family set their sights on a new enterprise, transforming the shop into The Garage Cafe & Lounge.
Garage Cafe & Lounge/Facebook
The restaurant was just unveiled last year, but much of the character of the classic car shop remains though its auto-themed decor and details.
Matthew Costanza/Google
The dining area is surprisingly spacious, as it occupies the three former auto bays.
Matthew Costanza/Google
However, one of the first things you’ll notice when you step inside The Garage Cafe & Lounge is the abundance of homemade sweets and treats on display behind the counter. Prepare your taste buds for an epic experience!
Matthew Costanza/Google
The cafe offers all kinds of baked goods, from cookies to whoopie pies.
Garage Cafe & Lounge/Facebook

Related Stories

The Humble Restaurant That's Way Out In The Boonies But So Worth The Drive From Buffalo

The Humble Restaurant That's Way Out In The Boonies But So Worth The Drive From Buffalo

 The Most Mouthwatering Pierogis Are Waiting For You Inside This Hidden Buffalo Kitchen

The Most Mouthwatering Pierogis Are Waiting For You Inside This Hidden Buffalo Kitchen

 The Unassuming Restaurant In Buffalo That Serves The Best Southern Food You'll Ever Taste

The Unassuming Restaurant In Buffalo That Serves The Best Southern Food You'll Ever Taste
The most delicious of all - and the one that has already earned this new eatery a strong reputation - are the hand-rolled cinnamon buns.
Garage Cafe & Lounge/Facebook
The buns are baked from scratch and sell out quite quickly on weekends, so if you wake up craving one on Saturday or Sunday, head to The Garage as fast as you can!
Adam Carter/Google
Though the cinnamon buns are certainly the stars of the show, the entire breakfast menu here is phenomenal. The French Toast Casserole is an excellent option, especially when paired with mimosas or even wine slushies.
jill n/TripAdvisor
Lunch and dinner are equally impressive at The Garage. From tasty sandwiches to buckets of meatballs slathered in mouthwatering BBQ sauce, it’s hard to leave this eatery anything less than stuffed.
Jane B/TripAdvisor
In addition to the tasty food and upbeat atmosphere, The Garage also hosts frequent live music nights and other fun events.
Garage Cafe & Lounge/Facebook
The Garage Cafe & Lounge is one of Buffalo’s best new restaurants, and it’s definitely time to discover it for yourself.
Matthew Costanza/Google
The Garage Cafe & Lounge is located at 1127 Hertel Ave., Buffalo, NY 14216. The restaurant is open every day except Mondays. Its hours are:

Tuesday: 11 a.m. to 8 p.m.,
Wednesday & Thursday: 11 a.m. to 9 p.m.
Friday: 11 a.m. to 10 p.m.
Saturday: 9 a.m. to 9 p.m.
Sunday: 9 a.m. to 5 p.m.

To learn more about this unique restaurant, including a peek at the menus and information about upcoming events, visit The Garage Cafe & Lounge Facebook page here.

Did you know that this auto repair shop is now a tasty eatery? For more unique eats around the Queen City, read about how You Shouldn’t Let The Outside Fool You, This Barbeque Restaurant In Buffalo Is A True Hidden Gem!

OnlyInYourState may earn compensation through affiliate links in this article. As an Amazon Associate, we earn from qualifying purchases.

Related Articles

Featured Addresses
1127 Hertel Ave, Buffalo, NY 14216, USA