There are many hidden gems in New Mexico, but did you know there’s an entire town that’s a secret to most? This tiny town off Highway 60 might be small but it sure is sweet. The people will steal your heart, but only if the baked goods don’t first. Within Pie Town is the town’s cafe: Pie Town Cafe! This little restaurant and bakery serves up some of the most unique pies in New Mexico with every flavor from Mango Chile to Green Apple with pinon nuts. Besides pies, this cafe serves up one of the best green chile cheeseburgers in the state. Get ready to be blown away by the pies at this one-of-a-kind cafe in Pie Town, New Mexico.

Welcome to Pie Town Cafe!
Rich D/TripAdvisor
If you've never been to Pie Town before, you're in for a treat.
conda richards/Google Local
This Catron County town jokes about being "3.14 miles from the middle of nowhere." This town is seriously small, with a population of 186. Even though it's tiny, it's also been nicknamed America’s Friendliest Little Town, so you'll feel right at home in no time.
Even though the streets of Pie Town aren't lined with sugar, this cafe will give you your sweets fix.
Ed Figueroa/Google Local
Pie Town Cafe is obviously home to some delicious pies! You'll find rotating flavors at this wholesome cafe.

Related Stories

Get Fresh Pastries At Clafoutis, An Fantastic French Bakery In New Mexico

Get Fresh Pastries At Clafoutis, An Fantastic French Bakery In New Mexico

 Tucked Away In Small Town New Mexico Is Passion Pie Cafe, An Unassuming Bakery And Cafe

Tucked Away In Small Town New Mexico Is Passion Pie Cafe, An Unassuming Bakery And Cafe

 Michael's Kitchen Restaurant & Bakery Has Been Serving Up Delicious Food In New Mexico Since 1974

Michael's Kitchen Restaurant & Bakery Has Been Serving Up Delicious Food In New Mexico Since 1974
One of the best parts about their pies is how unique their flavors are.
Kate Gillispie/Google Local
You'll find interesting flavors of pie here such as Mango Red Chile or the infamous Apple Green Chile. Even these pies are an ode to the Land of Enchantment, and they're as delicious as ever.
Pie Town Cafe is also a great place for a wholesome meal.
BSteve1981/TripAdvisor
This cafe is one of those places where everyone knows your name, and you won't regret choosing any item from the menu.
Especially, their green chile cheeseburger!
sondra010103/TripAdvisor
This GCCB in the sweet town of Pie Town is award-winning, and you simply need to try it.
It might be a bit of a trek to this sweet town, but we promise it'll be so worth it.
Joan C/TripAdvisor
Address: 5596 US-60, Pie Town, NM, 87827
Phone: (575) 772-2700

For more of the latest information on Pie Town Cafe, you can visit their Facebook page right here.

Have you ever had a unique slice of pie at Pie Town Cafe? What did you think? We’d love to hear your thoughts in the comments!

To learn more about Pie Town, check out our previous article to learn more about this secret town that will steal your heart – and sweet tooth.

OnlyInYourState may earn compensation through affiliate links in this article. As an Amazon Associate, we earn from qualifying purchases.

Related Articles

Explore New Mexico