Plenty of restaurants have a signature dish or a particular specialty, however, it’s not very often that you find an eatery that serves just one item, but they do exist – and Pie-O-Neer is one of them. Focusing solely on pies, the eatery has perfected the classic dessert, winning countless awards over the years. Don’t expect the single-item menu to make ordering any easier, though. There are a ton of fillings and flavors to choose from. Take a look:

Please note, Pie O Neer is temporarily closed.

Along a stretch of highway in the community of Pie Town, you’ll find a little slice of Heaven, which is officially known as Pie-O-Neer.
warmwaterbeaches61/TripAdvisor
Somewhat of an icon, the roadside eatery has been satisfying sweet tooths since 1995.
Jim C/TripAdvisor
They say “stick to what you do best” – and Pie-O-Neer definitely proves that old adage to be true.
Barry M/TripAdvisor
Over the years, the tiny eatery, which serves only pie, has won countless awards and been featured in several TV shows.
And after one bite, you’ll certainly agree that the restaurant is worthy of its accolades.
Erin Slonaker/Google
So, just what makes the pies so good? Well, for one, Pie-O-Neer pies are made using only fresh or frozen fruit – no canned fruits.
B H/TripAdvisor
Also, the pies contain no preservatives and very little sugar.

Related Stories

Caliche's Frozen Custard In New Mexico Is Home To An Ice Cream Sundae You Won't Find Anywhere Else

Caliche's Frozen Custard In New Mexico Is Home To An Ice Cream Sundae You Won't Find Anywhere Else

 Inspire Your Taste Buds With The Decadent Desserts At Eldora Chocolate In New Mexico

Inspire Your Taste Buds With The Decadent Desserts At Eldora Chocolate In New Mexico

 Celebrate National Pecan Month With A Sweet Treat From One Of These New Mexico Shops

Celebrate National Pecan Month With A Sweet Treat From One Of These New Mexico Shops
The famous pies are sold whole as well as by the slice.
Andrew Rodney/TripAdvisor
To keep things moving along, customers simply step up to the pie bar and select their favorite slice.
Andrew Rodney/TripAdvisor
Pie may be the only thing on the menu, but that doesn’t mean there’s a limited selection.
Greg M/TripAdvisor
The expansive offering includes everything from classics, like apple and meringue pies, to signature Chile pies.
Enjoy your pie as-is or a la mode, at home or on-site. Either way, it’s sure to please your palate.
Pie-O-Neer/Facebook
Have a favorite type of pie? Just call Pie-O-Neer before your visit and they’ll save you a slice.
Kirk H/TripAdvisor
It’s as easy as pie.
So, are you ready to sample what's been referred to as the best pie in the universe?
Andrew Rodney/TripAdvisor

Pie-O-Neer Pies is open seasonally from Pi Day (otherwise known as March 14th) through Thanksgiving. During that time, it’s open Thursday, Friday, and Saturday, from 11:30 a.m. – 4 p.m. For more information, call (575) 772-2711. You can also visit the Pie-O-Neer website or Facebook page.

Have you ever been to this popular pie shop? If so, what kind of pie did you try? Did it live up to its hype? Tell us in the comments section.

OnlyInYourState may earn compensation through affiliate links in this article. As an Amazon Associate, we earn from qualifying purchases.

Related Articles

Explore New Mexico

Featured Addresses
5613 US-60, Pie Town, NM 87827, USA