This Off-The-Beaten Path Eatery In New Jersey Is Known For Its Mouthwatering Pancakes
By Raymond Goldfield|Published October 02, 2022
×
Raymond Goldfield
Author
Raymond Goldfield is a life-long New Jersey resident and an avid traveler and foodie who can be usually found on the Jersey Shore during the offseason or checking out the latest seasonal flavors at The Bent Spoon in Princeton. He has been working for Only In Your State for since early 2022, where he writes for New Jersey and Iowa and edits the Mid-Atlantic region. He can also be found writing about pop culture for GeekDad. When at home, he enjoys reading comic books and is part of The Rabbitt Stew podcast team. While New Jersey is his home base, he travels regularly and has visited Virginia, Florida, Maine, Minnesota, and Canada as well as all of NJ's border states. Ultimate travel goal? Visit all the best buffets in the United States.
Barnegat Light is one of NJ’s most underrated towns, located far down the Jersey Shore away from the hustle and bustle of the boardwalks. But hungry diners come streaming into the little town every morning for one reason – to get a taste of the pancakes at Mustache Bill’s diner. This quirky diner not only has some of the best pancakes in New Jersey, but its short-order cooks have been delighting visitors for years by shaping the pancake batter into unique shapes. The rest of the menu delivers as well, but this one-of-a-kind dinner and a show is the kind of experience you can only get in New Jersey.
Have you eaten at Mustache Bill’s Diner down at the Jersey Shore? Let us know your thoughts about the best pancakes in New Jersey in the comments section – and make sure to let us know what your special request was shaped like! If you’re planning to make the trip to Barnegat Light, make sure to visit Mustache Bill’s website and Facebook page. For another hidden gem in New Jersey, check out this humble chicken shack.
OnlyInYourState may earn compensation through affiliate links in this article. As an Amazon Associate, we earn from qualifying purchases.