New Jersey may be small in terms of overall square mileage, but we pack a lot of strange stuff into our state nevertheless. We have loads of lore and many myths about miniature villages and things like portals to hell… you know, the usual. If you’re a fan of the supernatural, New Jersey has a lot to offer. However, if you are more interested in real-life mysteries, we have plenty of them too. Think you can solve these creepy crimes and strange disappearances? No one has for decades. Which of these unsolved mysteries in NJ is the eeriest to you? Let us know.

Related Stories

This Garden State Animal Sanctuary Makes For The Perfect New Jersey Day Trip

This Garden State Animal Sanctuary Makes For The Perfect New Jersey Day Trip

I've Lived In New Jersey, My Entire Life And I've Never Had Boardwalk Fries And Lemonade

I've Lived In New Jersey, My Entire Life And I've Never Had Boardwalk Fries And Lemonade

Anything Is Possible For Young Kids At This Immersive Children's Museum In New Jersey

Anything Is Possible For Young Kids At This Immersive Children's Museum In New Jersey

Do these stories give you the creeps? Which was the most chilling? Are there any other unsolved mysteries that you would add to the list? Which unsolved mysteries in NJ keep you awake at night? Let us know in the comments.

If you can’t get enough of New Jersey’s more spine-tingling tales, you might want to check out the spooky Shades of Death Road, or maybe embark upon a haunted New Jersey day trip… if you dare.

OnlyInYourState may earn compensation through affiliate links in this article. As an Amazon Associate, we earn from qualifying purchases.

More to Explore

Unsolved Mysteries in NJ

  1. What are some eerie unsolved mysteries in NJ? 

Every place has its cold cases and unsolved mysteries. Some of the eeriest unsolved mysteries in NJ are things such as:  

  • The disappearance of Gary Grant, Jr 
  • The disappearance of William Jones III  

 

2. What are some haunting cold cases in NJ?  

The list doesn’t stop at the above few; there are plenty of unsolved cold cases in NJ that still haunt investigators to this day, including cases like:  

  • The infamous Lindbergh kidnapping 
  • The sniper of Camden 

 

3. What are some interesting stories from NJ history?  

Of course, there’s more to New Jersey than its cold cases! Some truly interesting stories from NJ history include tales like: