What’s better than discovering an amazing new place to enjoy? Discovering an amazing new place that serves incredible food. While we love sharing secret gardens and secluded beaches, finding incredible places to dine in New Jersey can be equally as thrilling. If you agree, you’ll be delighted by these delectable dining spots hidden in plain sight. Get ready to take your taste buds on an adventure when you visit these hidden gem restaurants in New Jersey:

1. 15 Fox Place, Jersey City
Facebook/15 Fox Place
15 Fox Pl, Jersey City, NJ 07306, USA
Facebook/15 Fox Place
This unassuming homefront holds within it one of the finest Italian restaurants in the state. Admission is by reservation only and there is no menu; you're served multiple courses through the night, at a fixed price. The exclusive dining club has snagged some serious press and rave reviews for its fantastic food and seemingly endless dinner - come hungry. For more information, be sure to check out 15 Fox Place online.
2. Claudie's Chicken, Middletown
Facebook/Claudie's Chicken
Claudie's Chicken, 417 NJ-35, Red Bank, NJ 07701, USA
Facebook/Claudie's Chicken
Tucked away behind a gas station and sharing space with a convenience store, this restaurant serves up some incredible wings. You'll also find some great BBQ ribs and truly affordable prices. Curious to check out the menu? Head on over to Claudie's Chicken online.
3. Belford Bistro, Belford
Image/Google Maps
Belford Bistro, 870 Main St, Belford, NJ 07718, USA
Facebook/Belford Bistro
Strip mall gourmet? Absolutely. You'll find incredible steak and seafood here, along with a budget-friendly prix fixe dinner menu. Learn more by visiting Belford Bistro online.
4. The Walpack Inn, Walpack
Facebook/The Walpack Inn
The Walpack Inn Restaurant, 7 National Park Service Rd 615, Layton, NJ 07851, USA
Facebook/The Walpack Inn
This secluded Sussex County restaurant is miles from much of civilization, located in the Delaware Water Gap National Recreation Area. Diners will enjoy both amazing food and spectacular views, and may even spot a deer or two from the greenhouse. You'll love the charming atmosphere and lodge-like vibe. Seemingly in the middle of nowhere, The Walpack Inn Restaurant is one of the best hidden gem dining spots in New Jersey!
5. Gourmet Cafe, Parsippany
Image/Google

Related Stories

The Most Delicious Bakery Is Hiding Inside This Unassuming New Jersey Gas Station

The Most Delicious Bakery Is Hiding Inside This Unassuming New Jersey Gas Station

 A Secret Door Will Take You To An Underground Restaurant In New Jersey That Was Built In 1910

A Secret Door Will Take You To An Underground Restaurant In New Jersey That Was Built In 1910

 This Tiny Restaurant In New Jersey Always Has A Line Out The Door, And There's A Reason Why

This Tiny Restaurant In New Jersey Always Has A Line Out The Door, And There's A Reason Why
Gourmet Cafe, 136 Baldwin Rd, Parsippany-Troy Hills, NJ 07054, USA
Facebook/Gourmet Cafe
This exterior of this incredible Italian eatery blends right in with the rest of the strip mall but the food stands out; according to reviewers, so does the service. Visit the official website for the Gourmet Cafe to learn more and browse the menu.
6. Charlotte's Web, Dover
Charlotte's Web / Facebook
Charlotte's Web, 39 W Clinton St, Dover, NJ 07801, USA
Facebook/Charlotte's Web
One of our favorite hidden gem restaurants in New Jersey, Charlotte's Web is the very last building on a dead end street, making it quite a find! Charlotte's Web serves Italian-American cuisine in a welcoming environment that's worth seeking out, however. The family-owned business is a local favorite.
7. Matt's Red Rooster Grill, Flemington
Image/Matt's Red Rooster Grill
Matt's Red Rooster Grill, 22 Bloomfield Ave, Flemington, NJ 08822, USA
Image/Matt's Red Rooster Grill
This fantastic restaurant looks like any other charming old home, but you'll definitely want to stop in. Enjoy fresh food and seasonal menus with ever-changing dessert choices. Reviewers say walking in feels as if you're visiting a friend - a friend with some top-notch culinary skills. Head on over to the Matt's Red Rooster Grill website for more information.
8. Long Valley Pub & Brewery, Long Valley
Yelp/Doug K.
Long Valley Pub & Brewery at Restaurant Village, 1 Fairmount Rd, Long Valley, NJ 07853, USA
Facebook/Long Valley Brew Pub
Located in one of the best food towns in New Jersey, Long Valley Pub & Brewery is housed in a 200-year-old stone farmhouse. Enjoy outdoor dining and delicious food in a laid-back atmosphere.
9. Kitchen 519, Glendora
Images/Google Maps
Kitchen 519, 200 E Evesham Rd, Glendora, NJ 08029, USA
Facebook/Kitchen 519
It may not look like much from the outside, but the inside is quaint and the food is fabulous. Enjoy modern American cuisine and stellar seafood at this spot which also offers gluten-free and vegan/vegetarian options. Be sure to visit the official website to learn more about Kitchen 519.

These amazing New Jersey restaurants may be hard to find, but they’re absolutely worth the hunt. What are your favorite hidden restaurants in New Jersey? Be sure to let us know in the comments below — we’d love to hear from you!

Looking for more dining inspiration? Be sure to read about these 19 restaurants in New Jersey that you just have to try. Trust us; you won’t be disappointed!

OnlyInYourState may earn compensation through affiliate links in this article. As an Amazon Associate, we earn from qualifying purchases.

More to Explore

Hidden gem restaurants in New Jersey

Sarah M. | December 14, 2022

What are some unassuming restaurants to try in New Jersey?

Here in New Jersey, we take our dining pretty seriously. Whether you're on the hunt for the best burger or are craving something a bit fancier, you won't be disappointed by the Garden State's dining scene. In fact, even the restaurants that may not look like much on the outside can prove to be downright incredible. One such example is Val's Tavern. One of the most unassuming restaurants in New Jersey, Val's Tavern serves up mouthwatering lobster pizza that you just have to try. Learn more about why Val's Tavern is such a must-visit New Jersey restaurant.

Where can I find the best diners in New Jersey?

Any diner you visit in New Jersey is bound to be special. Whether it's the delightful menu, the friendly staff, or perhaps the legendary decor, there's something wonderfully nostalgic about visiting a diner. Some of the best diners in New Jersey include:

  • Tops Diner in East Newark
  • The Summit Diner in Summit
  • Vincentown Diner in Vincentown
  • Americana Diner in East Windsor
  • Tick Tock Diner in Clifton
  • State Line Diner in Mahwah
  • Salem Oak Diner in Salem
  • Jefferson Diner in Lake Hopatcong
  • Bendix Diner in Hasbrouck Heights
  • Skylark Diner in Edison
  • Ponzio's Diner in Cherry Hill

 

Are there any hole-in-the-wall restaurants in New Jersey?

You bet! Just like unassuming restaurants in New Jersey, true hole-in-the-wall restaurants are actually some of the best in the state. One prime example is Hot Rod's Hot Dogs in Glen Gardner. If you didn't know it already, New Jersey is pretty famous for its hot dogs, and Hot Rod's is one of the best. It's here you'll find an epic chili dog and lots of racing memorabilia. Learn more about the best hole-in-the-wall restaurants in New Jersey.

Related Articles

Explore New Jersey