10 Italian Restaurants In Maine That'll Make Your Taste Buds Explode
×
Michelle
Author
When folks think of food in Maine, they think of lobster rolls, fried haddock, maybe some steamers. They probably don’t go immediately for thoughts of meatballs and pizza. But, Maine might surprise you when it comes to delicious Italian food! From Portland to Presque Isle, we’ve got some delicious options that you must check out the next time you’re in the mood for something with a kick!
Since opening their doors in 2006, Rustica has insisted on making as much of their incredible food from scratch as possible. Try the mussels to start and then move on to any of the parm dishes. Try them out: 315 Main Street, Rockland / 207-594-0015
Advertisement
Advertisement
Enio's is a relative newcomer in a town where the food scene is becoming very notable. In addition to their every-night menu, which is already rich with handmade pastas and perfect stews. Speaking of stew, the seafood stew gets great reviews, as does the incredible wine list. Try them out: 347 Cottage Road, South Portland / 207-799-0207
The Cabin makes their own pizza dough, which is notable in a world where convenience (even among local businesses) often wins out. Get your pizza (or Italian sandwich) with a cold brew and you can't go wrong. Not interested in leaving the house? They deliver! Definitely check out the white garlic sauce - it's a hit! Check them out: 552 Washington Street, Bath / 207-443-6224
This small gem is popular among the theater crowd, but it's perfect for anyone looking for a delicious meal. Using farm fresh and local ingredients, Trattoria Athena cooks up a fusion of flavors that feel part Italian, part Mediterranean. Order the eggplant, tomato, mozzarella, prosciutto stack. Try them out: 25 Mill Street, Brunswick / 207-721-0700
Advertisement
With great food and hearty portions, you definitely won't leave hungry after a meal here. The porterhouse gets great reviews, but people consistently mention the unique and exciting martini list. Try the Gardenia, which comes with muddles cucumber and pepper! They even have a regulation bocce court for warm days where you have nothing to do but be happy and maybe a teensy bit tipsy. Check them out: 22 Broad Street, Bethel / 207-824-3496
Related Stories
This Maine City Is One Of The Best In The USA For Pizza
The Little Hole-In-The-Wall Restaurant That Serves The Best Pizza In Maine
These 10 Pizza Places In Maine Are So Good That Your Mouth May Explode
40 Paper prides themselves on being a bit of a contradiction. They are intimate and cozy, but their bar is quite large and very popular. They specialize in Italian, but you'll find that their dishes take influence from Spain, France and the surrounding Mediterranean. Start with the stuffed baby artichokes, which are filled with fresh goat cheese & prosciutto. From there, you pretty much can't go wrong. 40 Paper also has a private dining room ("PDR") for larger events. Try them out: 40 Washington Street, Camden / 207-230-0111
Advertisement
The good news is that the Crowe family's restaurant is just about the best place to grab the perfect slice with friends and family. Kids will love watching the experts throw their dough into the air and you'll appreciate the casual atmosphere that allows for good times and great beers. Bad news? They're seasonal which means you'll need to wait until tourist season for this one. But, do drop by when the doors open this spring! You'll be glad you did. Try them out: 46 Cottage Street, Bar Harbor / 207-288-5666
It's probably no surprise that Massimo's is included on this list. Since 2007, this Rome-born chef and his wife, Anne Marie have been serving incredibly authentic food to Bangor and beyond. You may have to wait a while for a table, but when you're seated you'll love everything from the negronis to the variety of pasta dishes. Try the caprese, which comes as a unique warm dish with the perfect layer of melted mozzarella. They've also got a fresh bakery you absolutely must experience. Try them out: 96 Hammond Street, Bangor / 207-945-5600
If you love pizza and love yourself, do yourself a favor and head to Slab. There were so many Portland options to include on this list, but this place was at the very top. Not your traditional Italian restaurant, Slab will serve you up some of the most incredible Sicilian street food with an incredible beer to match. The cozy vibe and live music feel more like a neighborhood bar than the best pizza in Portland. We may get some flack for this, but we're ready to defend this choice until our the very last hand slab crosses our lips. Try one for yourself: 25 Preble Street, Portland / 207-245-3088
Advertisement
Meanwhile is a must for anyone passing nearby. You'll love the wood-fired pizza and the homemade pastas, but the happy atmosphere might be just as loveable. While some feel it's a bit pricey, many know that it's definitely worth it. The brunch gets rave reviews, as does the Farmer pizza. Give it a taste and let us know what you thought! Try them out: 2 Cross Street, Belfast / 207-218-1288
What are your favorite Italian places in the state? Let us know on Facebook!
OnlyInYourState may earn compensation through affiliate links in this article. As an Amazon Associate, we earn from qualifying purchases.