8 Unexpected And Delicious Burgers You Can Only Find In Indiana
×
Elizabeth Crozier
Author
Indiana is a little-known hamburger paradise that is soon to be discovered. The state is full of wonderful restaurants that sell unexpected burgers you’ve got to try.
From sweet to savory toppings, these eateries have them all. Check it out:
Regularly voted one of the best burgers in the state, this restaurant has been in business since 2012. Each of its unique creations is topped with fresh ingredients and handmade seasonings. Interesting toppings like pulled pork, cookie butter, cheese curds, and even peanut butter and maple make each unexpected burger more intriguing than the last. Try them all at 2222 W Southport Rd. STE A, Indianapolis, IN 46217.
Advertisement
Advertisement
This iconic place has been in business since 1951. It is a classic diner that serves American favorites, and its burgers are to-die-for. Its most popular burger is the Claybaugh which has four types of cheese, bacon, mushrooms, and grilled onions. There is also a Philly burger with cream cheese. Find it at 1743 W Lusher Ave., Elkhart, IN 46517.
This Norse mythology-themed bar has been around since 2017 and features viking-themed burgers. The Leif Erikson burger is topped with peanut butter, bacon, and blackberry jam, and other specialty patties come with treats like fried jalapenos, smoked Gouda, and BBQ sauce. Stop by for dinner Thursday through Sunday at 1065 W Jefferson St., Franklin, IN 46131.
With two locations in the state, this fabulous restaurant is well-known for its unexpected burgers. Specialty ones include toppings like burnt cheese, fried eggs, grilled pineapple, peanut butter, and sweet chili sauce. Find locally sourced ingredients and grass-fed Angus beef at 137 E Ohio St., Indianapolis, IN 46204 and 12525 Old Meridian St. #100, Carmel, IN 46032.
Advertisement
Related Stories
This Itty Bitty Hot Dog House In Indiana Is Unexpectedly Awesome
The Lovely Louisiana-Style Restaurant In Indiana That Serves Up Authentic Creole Food
This Hoosier Hamburger House Has Been An Indiana Favorite Since 1930
Indiana's first and oldest drive-in has been around since 1929. It has been featured on national television shows and is known for making its own root beer. When it comes to burgers, the restaurant makes a wealth of unique ones. Several are topped with Miracle Whip while others come with peanut butter, chili, pineapple, and other unconventional toppings. Click here to learn more about this place from previous coverage.
This ancient eatery is a restaurant and museum all-in-one. It has been with us since 1900 and features a collection of vintage soda fountains that are a delight to behold. The most famous burger here is the GOM Cheese-brr-grr, which is like sloppy joe on toast. You can also get it without cheese. Find this classic meal and much more at 329 Washington St., Columbus, IN 47201.
Advertisement
With locations all over the world, this trendy restaurant definitely belongs in the Broad Ripple neighborhood. It is known for unique burger creations like the Bastard that is topped with mango, avocado, bacon, beetroot, and chia seeds. The unexpected burgers don't stop there, though. The Roadster is topped with huge onion rings. Try them all at 6320 Guilford Ave., Indianapolis, IN 46220.
This famous restaurant started out in 2003 and is known for its gigantic one-pound burger. If you can finish a whole one, you'll get your photo up on the wall and the right to brag to all your friends. The plethora of toppings to choose from include several different cheeses, jalapenos, bacon bits, and other specialty toppings that you can ask your server about. Get more details here.
For more fun places to eat, check out these seven restaurants in Indiana that seem totally out of place.
Where else in the Hoosier State can you find amazing unexpected burgers? Share your favorites with us below in the comments.
OnlyInYourState may earn compensation through affiliate links in this article. As an Amazon Associate, we earn from qualifying purchases.