People of Newburgh, rejoice! Actually, you know what? Make that, “Lovers of fried fish in Indiana, rejoice!” because we have found a little spot in small-town Indiana that serves up some of the best fried fish you’ll ever have in your life. It’s a little joint called The Tin Fish, and believe us when we say it. Is. Legendary.

All one needs to do is check out the restaurant's reviews to find out why we're so certain it's got the best fried fish in the Midwest.
Brian Young/Google Local
You'll find rave review after rave review filled with all sorts of praise for this unique little place, and we aren't surprised at all: it really is that good.
It's an unassuming little stop, with a family-friendly vibe and an overall sense of homey-ness.
Brian Young/Google Local
The Tin Fish was originally established in 2007, and it's truly been a staple of local lovers of seafood and good times ever since.
But let's take a moment to really appreciate the crown jewel of the menu: the best fried fish EVER.
The Tin Fish, Newburgh/Facebook
We're not sure how they get it so perfect every single time, but they do. Fried to a perfect point of being golden and crispy on the outside but juicy and delicious on the inside, we're pretty sure it just doesn't get tastier than this.

Related Stories

Enjoy An Endless, Enormous Buffet At The Journey In Indiana

Enjoy An Endless, Enormous Buffet At The Journey In Indiana

 There's A Delicious Steakhouse Hiding Inside This Old Indiana Stable That's Begging For A Visit

There's A Delicious Steakhouse Hiding Inside This Old Indiana Stable That's Begging For A Visit

 This Floating Restaurant In Indiana Serves Mouthwateringly Delicious Seafood

This Floating Restaurant In Indiana Serves Mouthwateringly Delicious Seafood
If fried food isn't really your thing (we get you), no worries - the menu is jam-packed from front to back with top-notch seafood-based dishes.
The Tin Fish, Newburgh/Facebook
We don't even know where to begin in terms of other excellent menu items to try; we love them all. You can't miss the mahi-mahi, mixed fish grill, oysters, mussels, or the sea scallops. Truly, you cannot go wrong, so what's left to do other than go nuts?
Come for the nothing-short-of-epic seafood (and that oh-so-scrumptious fried fish, too), and keep coming back for the good vibes.
Jennie.B/Google Local
The service at The Tin Fish is as friendly as the food is delish, and you're sure to become a fan immediately, already planning your return.
...a new Friday night tradition, anyone?
The Tin Fish, Newburgh/Facebook
We think yes.

We almost forgot to mention that they also do brunch! For the most up-to-date hours, menu info, and more, be sure to check out the official Tin Fish Restaurant website. Need more delicious fried fish in Indiana? Be sure to also try out our friends at Wheatley’s Restaurant.

OnlyInYourState may earn compensation through affiliate links in this article. As an Amazon Associate, we earn from qualifying purchases.

Related Articles

Explore Indiana

Featured Addresses
The Tin Fish, 707 State St, Newburgh, IN 47630, USA