Hidden away in small-town Middlebury, Indiana, is an amazing slice of paradise for all lovers of cheese (and honestly, if you’re not a fan of cheese, I’m not sure how to help you). Owned by local farmers and deep in Amish roots and heritage, this little cheese shop isn’t so little – since 1979, this amazing tour de force of all things dairy came to the forefront of Indiana’s Amish scene, and for good reason: it might just be home to the best cheeses and butter in the entire Midwest (and that’s saying a lot). This huge cheese shop in Indiana is a place where you could probably get lost for hours in the best way possible. Check it out!

Welcome to Heritage Ridge Creamery, home of Indiana's finest cheese.
Allison Stuby/Google Local
From the moment you walk in, you'll be amazed at the sheer variety of cheese. I bet you didn't know you could go this nuts with it... and speaking of nuts, plenty of the cheeses you'll find here go great with 'em.
Each cheese is made fresh by milk supplied by local farmers that all pass the quality test.
Jon Meyer/TripAdvisor
Originally, this creamery started as a small local market for Amish farmers that still used milk cans.
Over the years, though, it grew, and now, more than five decades later, it's a place where you could kill a whole afternoon if you wanted.
Denise Barlock/Google Local
It's not just cheese and butter going on around here; you'll also find an amazing selection of fresh jams, charcuterie necessities, meats, and more.

Related Stories

You Could Spend Hours At This Outdoor Marketplace In Indiana

You Could Spend Hours At This Outdoor Marketplace In Indiana

 The Quirky Market In Indiana Where You’ll Find Terrific Treasures

The Quirky Market In Indiana Where You’ll Find Terrific Treasures

 The Charming Out Of The Way Flea Market In Indiana You Won’t Soon Forget

The Charming Out Of The Way Flea Market In Indiana You Won’t Soon Forget
It is, however, definitely most famous for its cheese.
Heritage Ridge Creamery/Facebook
And I'm not at all surprised; once you've tried the cheese from Heritage Ridge Creamery, you'll probably wonder how you ever had cheese from anywhere else.
It's a step above the rest, and that much will become very obvious very fast.
Jon Meyer/TripAdvisor
The focus was once on both barreled and longhorn cheeses, though today, the longhorn stirred-curd variety reigns king. And goodness, are they amazing at what they do!
You won't want to leave without packing some up to bring with you.
Larry Taylor/Google Local
Get one, or get one hundred... I'm not here to judge. I'm just here to encourage your cheese-consuming choices.
But, in all seriousness, this huge cheese shop in Indiana really is so much more than "just" cheese.
Juan Galvan/Google Local
It's an experience... and a delicious one at that.

For more information about this udderly (see what I did there?) incredible cheese smorgasbord in the heart of northern Indiana’s Amish country, you’ll want to visit the official Heritage Ridge Creamery website.

Need somewhere to stay while you’re in the Middlebury-Shipshewana area? No worries – our friends at VRBO have your back. Need something else to do while you’re here? Check out one of the most epic flea markets in Indiana, located right here in town.

OnlyInYourState may earn compensation through affiliate links in this article. As an Amazon Associate, we earn from qualifying purchases.

Related Articles

Explore Indiana

Featured Addresses
Heritage Ridge Creamery, 11275 W 250 N, Middlebury, IN 46540, USA