Sometimes, the soul wants what the soul wants – and sometimes, what the soul wants is some delicious, incredibly authentic Italian food. I get it, which is why I’ve spent (probably way too much) time checking out some of the all-time best spots for Italian food in Indiana. Now, get this: the best Italian food in Indiana is not necessarily found in a standalone brick-and-mortar building or a chain place. Nope! It’s nestled within a strip mall in Indianapolis: one of the best places to eat in Indiana if you’re looking for it. Check it out:

Since 1992, Vito's has been serving up some of the best Italian food you'll ever find in the Midwest.
Vito Provolone's/Facebook
Don't let its location within a strip mall fool you: it's the real deal, and it's excellent for a night out.
The overall vibe is casual but not lazy; it's not elegant, per se, but it's nice.
Vito Provolone's/Facebook
If you're looking to be impressed, the décor is not where you want to turn. For that, we refer to the menu, which is filled top-to-bottom with incredible dining options.
It doesn't even matter what you choose. It's all amazing.
Vito Provolone's/Facebook
You can go with classics like pizza, spaghetti and meatballs, fettuccine alfredo, and more. Or, you can get a little more creative and get something like, say, the delicious veggie lasagna.

Related Stories

Open Since 1955, Bruno's Has Been Serving Pizza In West Lafayette, Indiana Longer Than Any Other Restaurant

Open Since 1955, Bruno's Has Been Serving Pizza In West Lafayette, Indiana Longer Than Any Other Restaurant

 If Pasta Is Your Love Language, You'll Be In Heaven At Nicole-Taylor's In Indiana

If Pasta Is Your Love Language, You'll Be In Heaven At Nicole-Taylor's In Indiana

 Farina's Supper Club Is A Romantic Restaurant In Indiana That’s Straight Out Of A Fairytale

Farina's Supper Club Is A Romantic Restaurant In Indiana That’s Straight Out Of A Fairytale
The seafood lasagna (pictured below) is also pretty amazing, and you'll only find it here.
Vito Provolone's/Facebook
Vito Provolone's isn't open on Sundays, so do plan accordingly. That's okay, though - it just makes us value the other six days of the week that much more. If we could come out and have lunch (and/or) dinner at Vito Provolone's, we would.
Of course, you won't be able to resist wrapping up your killer meal with some delectable desserts.
Vito Provolone's/Facebook
You can also take your pick from lots of delicious wines and beers, many of which are imports. Vito Provolone's is awesome for a little self-care, a date night, a birthday, or just because.
No matter what the occasion is (or isn't), one thing's for sure: you won't find authentic Italian food in a strip mall that's ever as good as this.
Vito Provolone's/Facebook
...seriously, ever.

For the most up-to-date hours, menu, specials, and more, you’ll definitely want to check out the official Vito Provolone’s website. You might also want to check out its official Facebook page. What’s your favorite place to grab Italian food in Indiana? Let me know in the comments – and tell me about your favorites by filling out this form. You might just see your picks featured sometime.

OnlyInYourState may earn compensation through affiliate links in this article. As an Amazon Associate, we earn from qualifying purchases.

Related Articles

Explore Indiana

Featured Addresses
Vito Provolone's, 8031 S Meridian St, Indianapolis, IN 46217, USA