If there’s one thing Hoosiers love (okay, besides our traditional breaded tenderloin), it’s a good old-fashioned Amish bakery. There’s just something about the Amish touch that makes certain foods simply magical, and the best place to indulge in said magic is, of course, at one of the best Amish bakeries in Indiana. Yoder’s Hand-Rolled Pretzels is located in the heart of Amish country: Shipshewana, Indiana. And you can trust us when we say they’re basically amazing.

You've probably never had a pretzel quite like the ones lovingly crafted, baked, and served here.
Yoder's Hand Rolled Pretzels/Facebook
Home cooking is an Amish tradition, and they're known for taking great pride in high-quality goods and services... especially in their food.
Shipshewana is a mostly-Amish community in Lagrange County.
Ken Ratcliff/Flickr
This area has the highest number of Amish in the entire Hoosier State, and that's wonderful because it means more delightful shops, goods, and tasty dishes than the rest of us English folks know what to do with!
Yoder's Hand-Rolled Pretzels is one of many must-visit establishments in Shipshewana, and for good reason.
Yoder's Hand Rolled Pretzels/Facebook
The pretzels are all made from scratch, by hand, in-house. Yoder's is so popular that it goes through about 600 pounds of flour every week - that adds up to over 15 tons of flour each year.

Related Stories

Sundae's In Indiana Serves The Best Ice Cream In The Midwest

Sundae's In Indiana Serves The Best Ice Cream In The Midwest

 Choose From More Than 15 Flavors Of Scrumptious Pie When You Visit Lisa's Pie Shop In Indiana

Choose From More Than 15 Flavors Of Scrumptious Pie When You Visit Lisa's Pie Shop In Indiana

 This One-Of-A-Kind Festival In Indiana Is A Chocolate Lover’s Dream Come True

This One-Of-A-Kind Festival In Indiana Is A Chocolate Lover’s Dream Come True
The serving sizes are generous, to say the least.
Yoder's Hand Rolled Pretzels/Facebook
There's so much one can do with one of these pretzels other than eat it on its own.
You can indulge in one of the most deliciously savory pretzel-based sandwiches you've ever had in your life, for one.
Yoder's Hand Rolled Pretzels/Facebook
The combination of firm and soft bread textures is just made better by the salt carefully sprinkled on top. These enormous pretzels make some incredible BLTs that you've got to taste to believe!
Everyone who comes in is made to feel like family, and that atmosphere is what keeps people coming back...
William Womack/Google Local
...well, that, and the incredible Amish pretzels you'll find here, too.

Yoder’s Hand-Rolled Pretzels is closed on Sundays, but open from 9 a.m. to 5 p.m. on Saturdays, Tuesdays, and Wednesdays, and from 11 a.m. to 5 p.m. on Thursday, Friday, and Monday.

If you’d like to learn about another one of our favorite Amish bakeries in Indiana, you can do so here.

Have you ever tried one of the amazing pretzels at Yoder’s?

OnlyInYourState may earn compensation through affiliate links in this article. As an Amazon Associate, we earn from qualifying purchases.

Related Articles

Explore Indiana

Featured Addresses
463 S Van Buren St, Shipshewana, IN 46565, USA