When it comes to warmer weather, what kind of desserts and refreshments tend to come to mind? Let us take a guess: popsicles. Ice cream. Milkshakes. Oooh, that’s the one – milkshakes. Honestly, we’re pretty sure that there’s no warm-weather dessert that works as perfectly year-round more than the old-fashioned milkshake, and we discovered a little mom-and-pop shop in Indiana that has some of THE best milkshakes you’ll have ever tasted. Come check out the local milkshake bar in Indiana that’s got all the locals raving, no matter what time of year it is (but especially when the temps are warm)! You’ve never seen outrageous milkshakes in Indiana like these before!

Gordon's Milkshake Bar is nestled in two Indiana cities: Carmel and Indy.
Gordon's Milkshake Bar/Facebook
The Carmel location can be found on West Main Street. The Indy location is on Mass Ave. Trust us, you can't miss it.
It's the combination of modern decor and old-school nostalgia that make this place so wonderful.
Gordon's Milkshake Bar/Facebook
...well, that, and the milkshakes are outrageously good.
No matter what your sweet tooth is whispering in your ear, you're sure to find something to scratch that itch right here at Gordon's Milkshake Bar.
Gordon's Milkshake Bar/Facebook
This might be one of, if not THE, first-ever milkshake bars in Indiana of its kind. It's a unique idea and it's pulled off perfectly by the delightful and caring staff, who will always greet you with a sunny smile and lovely conversation.

Related Stories

There’s A Bakery On This Small Farm In Indiana And You Have To Visit

There’s A Bakery On This Small Farm In Indiana And You Have To Visit

 Locals Can't Get Enough Of The Artisan Creations At This Family-Run Bakery In Indiana

Locals Can't Get Enough Of The Artisan Creations At This Family-Run Bakery In Indiana

 This Old-School Candy Shop Makes The Best Homemade Fudge In Indiana

This Old-School Candy Shop Makes The Best Homemade Fudge In Indiana
Of course, the milkshakes aren't ALL there is to Gordon's. Oh, no. There are other desserts to die for, too, so leave room.
Gordon's Milkshake Bar/Facebook
Are you a fan of cobbler? Good, try the cobbler here and you'll never want one from anywhere else. Get an ice cream cone, some kind of baked deliciousness, or anything else your sweet tooth begs for.
Of course, we personally will always be all about these shakes, because it doesn't get much better than Gordon's.
Gordon's Milkshake Bar/Facebook
You won't find any run-of-the-mill flavors here, either. Sure, you can get a traditional chocolate shake - but why do that when you can get something like a chocolate fudge Oreo shake instead?
For the health-conscious, don't worry - frozen yogurt is available, and so are fruit-based dessert options!
Gordon's Milkshake Bar/Facebook

We are ridiculously proud to call Gordon’s Milkshake Bar one of our own. It’s an Indiana legend that has folks driving in from all over the Midwest to try, so what are you waiting for? Come indulge in one of the most outrageous milkshakes in Indiana, and some of the best desserts in the Hoosier State.

Be sure to check out the official Gordon’s Milkshake Bar Facebook page for the most up-to-date hours and specials at this Indiana milkshake bar. What kind of amazing milkshakes will you get? Tell us your thoughts in the comments. We’re sure they’ll be delicious. And if you visit the Carmel location, stick around and discover why everyone calls this the friendliest town in Indiana.

OnlyInYourState may earn compensation through affiliate links in this article. As an Amazon Associate, we earn from qualifying purchases.

More to Explore

Best Restaurants In Indiana

Raymond Goldfield | May 05, 2023

What Are The Best Hidden Gem Restaurants In Indiana?

  • Das Dutchman Essenhaus is a massive Amish restaurant in Amish country, housed in a building that looks like an old barn. It's actually the largest restaurant in all of Indiana, but it's usually still crowded - because the food is delicious! Dig into dishes like ham steak or Amish fried chicken, and make sure to save room for dessert at the bakery - the homemade whoopie pies are a must-try.
  • Bonge's Tavern in tiny Perkinsville is one of the most remote restaurants in Indiana - but it's worth taking the trip! That's because this old-school watering hole, open since 1934, has been serving up some of the best pork tenderloin in the Hoosier State! The steaks and chocolate ganache cake are also favorites, and the outdoor dining is a great way to enjoy your meal in the warmer months.

 

Where Can I Find The Best Desserts In Indiana? 

  • Pea-Fections is a popular lunch restaurant in Vincennes, known for its reasonably priced lunch menu of soups and salads - and for its massive dessert menu! There's only one specialty here, and it's cheesecake. Made fresh in house, the creamy, indulgent cheesecakes come in a wide variety of flavors that is always changing. You'll want to come back again and again to try them all.
  • Ivanhoe's in Upland is another popular lunch spot - this one specializing in humble fare like nachos and chicken fingers - but the starring attraction is the massive milkshake and sundae bar. You can choose from over 100 flavors of desserts, including seasonal ones like Girl Scouts Thin Mints. This small-town snack shack has been owned and operated by the same family since 1965, and it's a must-visit.

Related Articles

Explore Indiana

Featured Addresses
865 Massachusetts Ave, Indianapolis, IN 46204, USA
816 W Main St, Carmel, IN 46032, USA