Just when you thought that a pie couldn’t get any better, a bakery in Atlanta, Indiana decided to up the stakes. Creating the most outrageous Hoosier pies you’ll ever see or taste, this place is a must-visit if you’ve got a sweet tooth.

You’ve never seen pies like these. Scroll on and get a glimpse at the masterpieces found at this shop:

Lisa's Pie Shop on the north side of Indiana is an award-winning bakeshop that is known for its unique takes on classic pies. You'll certainly find all your favorites, but they'll be bigger and better than ever.
TripAdvisor/DMJA21
This little family-owned bakery has been making outrageous Hoosier pies for more than 20 years. Locals know that this is the shop to go to if you want to impress a party.
Google/J Crozier
You'll find everything from fruit pies to cream pies to specialty ones like pecan, caramel apple walnut, raisin, and Hershey bar. For a true indulgence, try the classic sugar cream pie or other cream pies like peanut butter, lemon, butterscotch, and coconut.
Facebook/Lisa's Pie Shop

Related Stories

The Ice Cream Parlor In Indiana That's So Worth Waiting In Line For

The Ice Cream Parlor In Indiana That's So Worth Waiting In Line For

 Devour The Best Homemade Sticky Buns At This Bakery In Indiana

Devour The Best Homemade Sticky Buns At This Bakery In Indiana

 This Great Depression-Era Ice Cream And Candy Store In Indiana Is Simply Charming

This Great Depression-Era Ice Cream And Candy Store In Indiana Is Simply Charming
By way of unique fruit pies, you'll find apple, peach, pumpkin, blueberry, cherry, strawberry rhubarb, and many more.
Facebook/Lisa's Pie Shop
In addition to these outrageous Hoosier pies that are just so pretty to look at, locals also come in for additional baked goods. The shop makes excellent cookies, pumpkin rolls, bread, and quiches.
Facebook/Lisa's Pie Shop
We can't talk about Lisa's Pie Shop without mentioning its unusual method of shipping its famous pies. If you love the flavor and don't care that the design isn't there, you can have the filling and crust shipped to you in a jar. Check the website (link below) for details.
Facebook/Lisa's Pie Shop
With all these awards, you know the pies are good. Locals order their holiday pies well in advance to ensure they get them because they know this is the best spot in town, and possibly the whole nation.
Facebook/Lisa's Pie Shop

Lisa’s Pie Shop is open Tuesday between 10 a.m. and 6 p.m, Wednesday through Friday between 8 a.m. and 6 p.m., and Saturday between 10 a.m. and 5 p.m. Get more details on its website or Facebook page.

Address: 5995 US-31, Atlanta, IN, 46031

For more like this, check out these nine unique bakeries in Indiana that everyone loves.

If you’ve ever tried one of the outrageous Hoosier pies from this bakery, we’d love to hear from you. Please share your experiences with us below in the comments.

OnlyInYourState may earn compensation through affiliate links in this article. As an Amazon Associate, we earn from qualifying purchases.

Related Articles

Explore Indiana