There’s a little pizzeria in Evansville, Indiana that few Hoosiers know exists. Get pizza by the slice at this fabulous hole-in-the-wall restaurant that belongs on every pizza lover’s bucket list.

When you’re looking for a laid back hang-out with budget-friendly food and friendly service, try this marvelous spot. Check it out:

By The Slice Pizzeria in Southern Indiana is a college-town favorite that all the locals love. It has been in business since 1994 and is one of the only places in the state where you can buy a single slice of savory pie.
Google/Matthew Frankic
The interior is cozy and eccentric with booths, tables, and even games in the back. You'll be greeted by pre-baked pizzas and a slew of unique decorations that grace the walls.
Google/Abdul Sunny
This local hang-out is popular with young and old alike. It is nearly right across the street from the University of Evansville and shares a corner of Lincoln Avenue with a gelato shop, an esports center, and a gift shop.
Google/Marshall Ray

Related Stories

This Lesser-Known Restaurant In Indiana's Own Little Italy Is A Genuine Gem

This Lesser-Known Restaurant In Indiana's Own Little Italy Is A Genuine Gem

 Hoosiers Can't Get Enough Of The Food From This Pint-Sized Pizza Place In Indiana

Hoosiers Can't Get Enough Of The Food From This Pint-Sized Pizza Place In Indiana

 This Indiana Pizza Joint In The Middle Of Nowhere Is One Of The Best In The U.S.

This Indiana Pizza Joint In The Middle Of Nowhere Is One Of The Best In The U.S.
A single slice of pizza at this joint costs just a couple bucks, and you'll find a myriad of special types. Toppings like spinach, clams, bacon, gryo meat, and ranch are very popular here.
Google/Matthew Frankic
If you're looking for something resembling a New York slice, this little pizzeria will supply. The dough is made fresh and tastes like nothing else you'll find in the state. New toppings and flavor combinations are always being created, giving locals a reason to stop by often.
Google/Matthew Frankic
By The Slice Pizzeria is open six days a week. Hours are 11:16 a.m. to 9 p.m. Monday through Saturday, other than Wednesdays when the place closes at 10 p.m.
Google Maps

By The Slice Pizzeria is located at 2011 Lincoln Ave., Evansville, IN 47714.

For more like this, check out 13 hole-in-the-wall restaurants in Indiana that sell outrageously good food.

If you’ve ever been to this little pizzeria, we’d love to hear from you. Please share your experiences and photos with us below in the comments.

OnlyInYourState may earn compensation through affiliate links in this article. As an Amazon Associate, we earn from qualifying purchases.

Related Articles

Explore Indiana