By Courtney Johnston|Updated on May 10, 2021(Originally published May 05, 2021)
×
Courtney Johnston
Author
Courtney's originally from the East Coast, but has found a charming new home in Indiana. She loves checking out local music, reading, and trying new food. She's also a little too addicted to coffee and has a Maine Coon cat she answers to.
Up for a little adventure? As the weather starts to warm up, you might be looking for new ways to get out of the house and explore a little. Cure your cabin fever with the ultimate of Indiana road trips: a map of some of the most haunted places in Indiana. If you’re into ghost stories and creepy history, this road trip will give you your fill of some of the creepiest places in Indiana.
Take a look at our route here, starting in Evansville and ending in Elizabeth.
The Willard Library in Evansville is rumored to be haunted by "The Grey Lady" ghost. First sighted in the 1930s, the Grey Lady has been rumored to be spotted in this library dozens of times since. Police officers, library employees, and paranormal investigators have all confirmed sightings of this ghost. She's so popular she's got her own page on the Willard Library website.
Stepp Cemetery in Martinsville, Indiana has a rich history of haunting Hoosiers throughout the years.
Like with many Indiana ghost stories, accounts from witnesses vary. Some stories revolve around a screaming woman who was grief-stricken from the death of her baby. Another tells of a religious cult known as "The Crabbites" that were rumored to have met at the cemetery. Tales talk of hearing chanting and even seeing spirits.
No list of the creepiest places in Indiana would be complete without this former insane asylum! This hospital is now home to the Indiana Medical History Museum. In the mid-1800s, the insane asylum opened and tunnels were created to walk between the various hospital buildings. Patients who died in the hospital were also buried on the grounds. Screaming, moaning, footsteps, and even manifestations of former patients have been spotted on the grounds. You can see more photos of the museum on their website.
Legend has it that Old Man Moody came home late one night to find his house burning down, with his entire family dead inside. Moody's Light refers to Old Man Moody's orb searching for his lost family. While paranormal investigators claim no presence was found at the sight, locals still swear that Moody's light is real. Find out for yourself by visiting this old cornfield in Rensselaer.
This legend claims that the spirits of 200 children haunt this house in Gary, Indiana. This case is compared to the legendary Amityville horror legend. Former occupants report doors slamming, things moving, and spirits manifesting. Some residents even reported swarms of black flies congregating on the porch even after they were all exterminated. While many believe this legend to be a hoax, some residents of Gary swear by the legend. Dubious? Find out for yourself. (Please note, this residence may be occupied, so guests might not be allowed inside).
The stories of Primrose Road vary in detail, but all ultimately lead to chilling conclusions. Some variations claim you must drive between 20 to 30mph. If you drive over or under this speed limit, your car will die, your tires will suddenly go flat. Your cell phone also won't work and many claim you'll hear and see people running through the woods. Some claim a woman will appear and can either make your car disappear or grant you luck. Blood Rock is also located along this road and is rumored to move from place to place. Pictures of the rock are often seen with fog and orbs, suggesting paranormal activity.
The Monroe House on Monroe Street is sweetly nicknamed "The Demon House." While the origins of the house and legend are ambiguous, what is known is that the house has suffered numerous fires and fire-related deaths. Rumors of satanic rituals and possessions also exist. While this house is on private property, you can still drive by and maybe arrange a meeting with locals or the residents.
While most of the hype around Black Moon Manor was confirmed to be fake, it is still a popular tourist site for ghost hunters and lovers of haunted places. While some of the events that occurred here were admittedly forgeries, residents still claim haunting and paranormal activities exist. In fact, this manor was torn down a few years ago, making many question why. The grounds are now closed for tours, but you can drive by to see the spooky area and feel for a presence, if you dare.
Take a break from the road and stay overnight in this haunted inn - if you aren't too scared! Throughout the years, guests at this inn left accounts of strange sightings of a ghost called "The Blue Lady". This spirit is believed to have once been the wife of George Story. Legend says that if a blue light is turned on in the Garden Room, the spirit will appear. She always allegedly leaves blue items behind, such as ribbons. Check out their website for additional information.
Captain Francis McHarry, a former steamboat captain, is rumored to haunt this area. Legend states he was once stabbed and had a jealous, violent relationship with other steamboat captains. McCarry built his tomb before his death and claimed he wanted his body to remain upright in it, so he could curse and haunt other boats passing by, Though his body has since been moved to Louisville, Kentucky, boats and visitors claim his spirit and curse still remain in Indiana.
Think you have the guts to survive this ultimate haunted Indiana road trip? Do you have any spooky stops people should add?
OnlyInYourState may earn compensation through affiliate links in this article. As an Amazon Associate, we earn from qualifying purchases.
More to Explore
Indiana Road Trips
Lisa Sammons|May 10, 2021
What are some more haunted places in Indiana?
If you're looking for more of the creepiest places in Indiana, we've got you covered! If you're in Indianapolis, we've got a list. The Hannah House is truly haunted: it was once a part of the Underground Railroad, and many slaves tragically died in a fire. It is said that they can still be sensed there today. The Hoosier State even boasts an entire haunted town! Angola has been known throughout history as an anti-church town that had many resident witches and mediums.
What are some creepy cemeteries in Indiana?
Like most states, Indiana has a rich history of old cemeteries that are rumored to be haunted. We've got a list for you if you'd like to check some out. It's said that Batson Cemetery in Warren has a step that disappears on your way out! Greenlawn Cemetery in Vincennes is the oldest cemetery in Indiana at over 200 years old. Needless to say, it has a lot of history and a lot of stories to tell!
What are some Indiana ghost stories?
Hoosiers have plenty of stories they love to tell around the campfire. The Avon Bridge in Hendricks County had a troubled building in which a construction worker was said to have been buried alive. It was too costly to remove his body, so it was left inside of the bridge. It is said that you can still hear his screams even today. We've got a whole list of Indiana ghost stories for you: if you don't want to be scared, maybe don't go to any of the locations at night!
