7 Places In Indiana Where You Can Get The Most Mouth Watering Pie

Do you like pie? Of course you do! Everyone likes pie, right? Here are places in Indiana where you can get mouth watering pie! Be warned – I had to get some pie after writing this. Don’t be surprised if you find yourself craving some pie after reading it!

From their Facebook page.

"Mom’s Original" Dutch Apple Pie is one of the signature pies at this shop. It's made with layers of fresh apples, cinnamon, and sugar. The restaurant was actually founded around the love of this particular pie.

40 E Pine St, Zionsville
(317) 733-8717

Advertisement

Advertisement

Both from tripadvisor.com

Abe Martin Lodge has an incredible dining experience and it's known for its delicious mini peanut butter pie.

1405 State Road 46 West, Nashville
(812) 988-4418

Related Stories

These 11 Restaurants Serve The Best Hoosier Pie In Indiana

You've Never Tasted Anything Like These 10 Unique Desserts In Indiana

These 16 Donut Shops In Indiana Will Have Your Mouth Watering Uncontrollably

All three from tripadvisor.com.

This pie shop is known for their old fashioned sugar cream pie. They've been making homemade pie shells and high quality pies for over 50 years.

217 SE Greenville Ave Winchester
(765) 584-8401

http://www.yelp.com/biz/taylors-bakery-indianapolis

I know, this is a bakery – not a pie shop. But, this bakery does make incredible pastries (including a wide range of pies). They have apple and cherry pies that are available daily and seasonally you can get Key Lime, Pumpkin, and Pecan. This bakery actually made the news once for making deflated football pastries to mock the Patriots.

6216 Allisonville Rd Indianapolis
(317) 251-9575

Advertisement

Both images from their website.

Did you know Lisa’s Pie Shop is recognized as the best independent bakery in the United States? If you haven’t had pie from this shop you're missing out on the BEST pie in the US, not just Indiana. Hoosier pie lovers MUST try this pie.

5995 S US Highway 31, Atlanta
317 - 758 – 6944

Storefront picture from Google Maps.

Mom’s Homemade Pies is a bit of a mystery to anyone who hasn’t been there because their website and FB page don't give much away in terms of information (including no mouthwatering pie pictures to gawk at!) That being said, this is a pie shop that people rant and rave about. Their pies are all made from scratch and they're a great option for getting Christmas and Thanksgiving pies.

3700B South LaFountain Street, Kokomo
765-453-4417

7. Moore’s Pie Shop

While I was unable to find pictures (or much information) about this pie shop. I did find a lot of very positive customer reviews (even some really recent ones). For that reason, I decided to include it in the list even though I don’t have any pictures to go with it. Customers speak very highly of this being a great place to get your holiday pie. Pecan pie appears to be one of the favorites.

115 W Elm Street, Kokomo
(765) 457-2428

Unfortunately, I discovered there really aren’t that many pie shops in Indiana. However, the ones in Indiana are known to be incredible. Maybe there were other pie shops that just couldn’t compete. It’s also possible there are a few pie shops that don’t have much of an online existence making it hard for me to find them! Do you have a favorite type of pie? How about a favorite place to get pie? Share your thoughts with me in the comments!