One of the most popular food trails in Indiana, the Hoosier Pie Trail is a legendary journey that will take your sweet tooth to some of the best bakeries and restaurants in the state. The entire journey consists of 27 locations (and counting) compiled by the Indiana Foodways Alliance, and it spans the entire state, but we’ve developed a mini version that you can easily accomplish in a day or two.

Sugar cream pie may be the Indiana classic, but these bake shops and diners sell just about every kind you can imagine. Check ’em out:

Fuel up the car and enjoy a scenic drive through east-central Indiana on this near 4.5-hour drive to five of the best restaurants and bakeries on the Hoosier Pie Trail. You might need a designated driver for the sugar coma you'll be in by the end.
Google Maps/Only In Your State
1. Mrs. Wick's Pies & Restaurant
Facebook/Mrs. Wick's Pies & Restaurant
Facebook/Mrs. Wick's Pies & Restaurant
One of the most iconic places to enjoy a Hoosier pie is right here at this hot spot. They are known for having 34 different pies available every day. The pies are so famous that people even get them shipped to their homes.
Address: 100 North Cherry Street, Winchester, IN 47394
2. Bluebird Restaurant
Google/Chad McClellan
Facebook/Bluebird Restaurant
In business since the 1930s, this iconic spot is known for its sugar cream pies and fried chicken. There's no better spot in the state for comfort food than this classic diner.
Address: 158 East Main Street, Morristown, IN 46161

Related Stories

This Outstanding Outdoor Adventure In Indiana Is A Playground, Splash Pad, And Nature Trail All In One

This Outstanding Outdoor Adventure In Indiana Is A Playground, Splash Pad, And Nature Trail All In One

 5 Stops Everyone Must Make Along Indiana’s Chicken-Fried Steak Trail

5 Stops Everyone Must Make Along Indiana’s Chicken-Fried Steak Trail

 This Unique Painted Murals Trail Is Like Nothing Else You'll Find In Indiana

This Unique Painted Murals Trail Is Like Nothing Else You'll Find In Indiana
3. Korner's Kountry Kitchen
Facebook/Korners' Kountry Kitchen
Facebook/Korners' Kountry Kitchen
Known for its scratch-made food, this family-owned and operated restaurant is known for its pies as well as its BBQ and other country-style eats. Locals come in for breakfast, lunch, and dinner here.
Address: 559 Main Street, Brookville, IN 47012
4. Ahlemeyer Farms Bakery
Facebook/Ahlemeyer Farms Bakery
Facebook/Ahlemeyer Farms Bakery
Next on the Hoosier Pie Trail is a farm bakery known for is sugar cream pie. You'll actually find a wealth of phenomenal baked goods at this popular shop.
Address: 2034 17th Street, Columbus, IN 47201
5. Hive
Google/Breck Sparks
Facebook/Hive
This trendy breakfast, lunch, and dinner spot is known for its quick service and fresh food. Assorted pastries are available all day, and that includes an array of pies that are hard to resist.
Address: 2608 East 10th Street, Bloomington, IN 47408

To view the other 22 locations on this Hoosier Pie Trail, check out the entire list on the Indiana Foodways Alliance’s website here.

For more like this, check out these nine bakeries in Indiana that belong on every Hoosier’s bucket list.

Have you ever been to a bakery on this pie trail? If so, we’d love to hear from you. Please share your experiences and photos with us below in the comments.

OnlyInYourState may earn compensation through affiliate links in this article. As an Amazon Associate, we earn from qualifying purchases.

Related Articles

Explore Indiana