It may be a new year, but that doesn’t mean you should turn your back on all of your old habits, like eating at some of your favorite restaurants. If you love pizza (and we know you do), you’ll want to check out this incredible, historic pizzeria hiding in the Hoosier state.

Cafe Pizzaria/Facebook
Cafe Pizzaria in Bloomington is a historic pizza place nestled right off from the main IU campus. This restaurant opened in 1953 and has been serving up some of the best pizza in the area ever since.
Cafe Pizzaria/Facebook
This family-run business is a staple in Bloomington. Despite the large number of pizza places in the area, this restaurant has some of the most unique pizza you'll find around the state.
Cafe Pizzaria/Facebook
That's because every pizza is freshly handmade with secret ingredients. The dough is always freshly made. The cheese is ground in house, giving it a fresh and more distinct taste, while the sauce may be the real reason to seek out this pizza place.

Related Stories

The Hidden Nature Park In Indiana With Its Very Own Springs, Two Caves, And So Much More

The Hidden Nature Park In Indiana With Its Very Own Springs, Two Caves, And So Much More

 In 2020, Indiana's Governor Holcomb Declared That 1 Million Trees Would Be Planted In 5 Years. We Did It Early.

In 2020, Indiana's Governor Holcomb Declared That 1 Million Trees Would Be Planted In 5 Years. We Did It Early.

 Trade Boots For Paddles On The Legendary 9 Lakes Challenge At Indiana's Chain O'Lakes State Park

Trade Boots For Paddles On The Legendary 9 Lakes Challenge At Indiana's Chain O'Lakes State Park
Cafe Pizzaria/Facebook
That's because the sauce is handmade and the recipe remains a family secret. With fresh ingredients and a unique sauce recipe, you really can't go wrong no matter which toppings you choose.
Cafe Pizzaria/Facebook
You'll also find handmade sandwiches and even hamburgers and other grilled foods, Monday through Friday until 4pm. Their tenderloin sandwich is definitely worth a try.
Cafe Pizzaria/Facebook
For delicious pizza unlike any other you've tried before, check out this historic, family-owned restaurant hiding in plain sight in the heart of Bloomington. You can visit at 405 E Kirkwood Ave, Bloomington, Indiana.

Will you be checking out this historic pizzeria in Indiana? For more great pizza places to try in the Hoosier state, check out this ultimate pizza bucket list in Indiana.

OnlyInYourState may earn compensation through affiliate links in this article. As an Amazon Associate, we earn from qualifying purchases.

Related Articles