Sometimes, we crave something that’s a little off the beaten path – or maybe a lot off the beaten path. Luckily for us, Indiana is filled with all kinds of strange, offbeat, or otherwise interesting places – and it might be fun to hop in the car and check out a bunch of them! We’ve done roadside attraction road trips before, but they’re super fun, so what’s one more? Get in the car, we’re gonna go look at some offbeat hidden gems in Indiana. Since it’s about a 7-hour drive to visit all our stops, why not make the dive into a weekend trip? We already have your ultimate road trip packing list created and ready for you to use, which makes it easy to start your adventure!

Google Maps
Our first stop is in Metamora, and it's a doozy!
Cliff T/TripAdvisor
This adorable shop is the epitome of mom-and-pop, and it’s filled top to bottom with cookie jars! It has, in fact, set the record for the largest cookie jar collection (with 2,653 jars, the last time they were counted). Grannie herself’s favorite cookie jar out of the entire bunch is the Roy Rogers one. It’s adorable. Everything about this shop is adorable. Oh, and the ice cream is to die for. When you read more about Metamora, you'll learn all about Grannie's legendary collection!
Up next is a stop at one of Indiana's oldest stores.
2799 S Cataract Rd, Spencer, IN 47460, USA
Cataract General Store/Facebook
Cataract General is one of the oldest general stores in the entire Hoosier State, having opened its doors in 1860. You can find lots of fun stuff you’ll have a hard time finding anywhere else, like old-school eight-ounce glass bottles of Coca-Cola – which Cataract General has been selling since forever. You’ll find all sorts of things here, from cookware to candy and everything in between. It's like stepping back in time when you visit Cataract General Store.

Related Stories

The Scenic Amish Country Route That Leads To 5 Old-Fashioned Bakeries, Furniture Stores, And More

The Scenic Amish Country Route That Leads To 5 Old-Fashioned Bakeries, Furniture Stores, And More

 The Ultimate Indiana Waterfalls Road Trip (Part 2: Southern Indiana)

The Ultimate Indiana Waterfalls Road Trip (Part 2: Southern Indiana)

 The 3-Hour Road Trip To The Some Of The Most Beautiful Waterfalls Is A Glorious Spring Adventure In Indiana

The 3-Hour Road Trip To The Some Of The Most Beautiful Waterfalls Is A Glorious Spring Adventure In Indiana
Science fiction fans are going to be stoked about this next stop: we're heading to Camby to check out WHO North America.
8901 IN-67, Camby, IN 46113, USA
WHO North America
The largest Dr. Who museum and shop in the world is hiding in Camby, Indiana. WHOvians from all over the world flock to this little spot to support one of the longest-running television shows in history. It’s one of the only shows we can think of where there are easily multiple generations of fans and doesn’t appear to have any intentions of slowing down any time soon. So that you can appreciate this stop on our road trip even more, be sure to get the full scoop about WHO North America!
Okay, in continuing the sci-fi theme - not really intentionally, it just sorta worked out like that - we'll make a stop at a monument to a strong, intelligent woman whose presence on television inspired many young ladies for decades.
308 W 4th St, Bloomington, IN 47404, USA
The Captain Janeway Statue/Facebook
The devotion reads "In honor of Captain Janeway’s leadership, and the accomplishments of those inspired by her character." It’s a statue commemorating the iconic female character from Star Trek: Voyager, and it represents so much more than just a fictional female hero. She inspired a generation – and she’s rightfully honored for it. You can read more about the Janeway statue on its official website.
Finally, we make a stop at a historically notable grave; it's that of someone you've surely heard of.
3800 Parnell Ave, Fort Wayne, IN 46805, USA
Gary Cobb/Flickr
John Chapman – known to most of us as "Johnny Appleseed", who was born in Massachusetts in 1774 – is buried here, at this little memorial park, in a very old grave protected by a wrought-iron fence. History buffs will appreciate this one; there’s something so intriguing about graves that are significantly older than even our grandparents. We can only hope to be remembered hundreds of years from now like Chapman has been. You can use the website Find-A-Grave for more information on Johnny Appleseed’s final resting place.

For the interactive Google Map of the trip above (which you can tweak any which way to suit your needs and interests), click here.

Which of these hidden gems in Indiana are your favorite? Have you been to any of these places? Tell us about them in the comments! We would love to hear about your experience or what you think of these hidden gems in Indiana.

OnlyInYourState may earn compensation through affiliate links in this article. As an Amazon Associate, we earn from qualifying purchases.

More to Explore

Unusual Places In Indiana

Katie Feldkamp | December 06, 2022

Where are some unique places to visit in Indiana?

There’s plenty to see and do in the Hoosier State, and sometimes it’s the unique places to visit in Indiana that are the most memorable. To narrow down the list a bit, the following are all in Indiana Amish Country. See how many of the following you know of or have seen for yourself:

  • Veni’s Sweet Shop in Nappanee
  • Nappanee Bakery and Treat Shoppe
  • The Old Bag Factory in Goshen
  • Bonneyville Mill County Park in Bristol
  • Grandma’s Pantry in Wakarusa
  • Dinky’s Auction Center in Montgomery

You can find out more about these and more unique places to visit in Indiana when you check out this article about the Indiana Amish Country.

What are some secret places in Indiana?

Did you know that there seem to be countless secret places in Indiana? It’s probably hard to truly know how many there are because, well, they’re secret. But here are a few hidden places that are Indiana’s best-kept secrets:

  • Pine Lake in Berne
  • Lyles Station Historic Community
  • Hardin Ridge in Bloomington
  • Rose Island in Charlestown
  • Prophetstown Water Park
  • Shades State Park in Waveland
  • Krider World’s Fair Garden Park in Middlebury

Related Articles