There is no shortage of amazing dining options in Illinois, but sometimes an item is so popular, it’s the early bird who gets the worm. A good reputation, loyal customers, and top-notch flavors are sometimes all that’s needed to go from freshly baked to totally sold-out. As a meticulous planner, I definitely schedule times to hit up my favorite spots so that I know I can get what I want while it’s still available. And the best bakery in Crystal Lake, Illinois is no exception — this place has been selling out since it first opened!

Pots and Pies Bakery, 67 E. Woodstock St., is a Parisian-themed, family-owned bakery in Crystal Lake helmed by mother-daughter duo Auriane Uglade and Xante Garmendia-Uglade.
best bakery in Crystal Lake, Illinois
Pots and Pies Bakery/Facebook
Since opening in October 2022, the store has been selling out almost daily of their homemade creations, despite making more than 100 pies a day — sometimes up to 230!
Pots and Pies Bakery/Facebook
Holiday desserts like Eggnog pie, chocolate pecan pie, and browned butter raspberry tarts became instant hits.
The bakery specializes in both savory pies and sweet pies, meaning it's completely acceptable to eat a pie for lunch and a pie for dessert.
Pots and Pies Bakery/Facebook
Above are the Bloom Moon pies: rose cardamom, lavender honey, and butterfly sweet pea with lemon and raspberry.
My pick will always be anything with pecans, so this Derby Pie is calling my name. But I'm definitely saving room for the apple stix, bear claws, and Kentucky Hot Brown.
Pots and Pies Bakery/Facebook

Related Stories

With Home-Baked Brownies And Fresh Whipped Cream, Dairy Delight In Illinois Will Satisfy Your Summer Sweet Tooth

With Home-Baked Brownies And Fresh Whipped Cream, Dairy Delight In Illinois Will Satisfy Your Summer Sweet Tooth

 Lines Form Down The Block Nightly At This Beloved Illinois Frozen Custard Shop

Lines Form Down The Block Nightly At This Beloved Illinois Frozen Custard Shop

 Galena Bakehouse Is A Bakery In Small-Town Illinois That Greets Everyone With Warm Welcomes... And Warm Empanadas

Galena Bakehouse Is A Bakery In Small-Town Illinois That Greets Everyone With Warm Welcomes... And Warm Empanadas
Not only does the bakery create pies, but it also turns out a wide variety of baked goods. This plate showcases the rainbow carrot tart, cherry cobbler, and blueberry scones.
Pots and Pies Bakery/Facebook
Imagine you walk in and see this — how are you going to possibly choose? My tip: Get a handful to save and share.
Pots and Pies Bakery/Facebook
Of course, if there's only one day a year you can visit, make it March 14 — aka, Pi(e) Day!
Pots and Pies Bakery/Facebook
Wash your order down with a bright and refreshing drink — the shop can whip up everything from iced cold brew lattes to sweet tea, cherry blossom soda, and more.
Pots and Pies Bakery/Facebook

Do you think Pots and Pies Bakery is the best bakery in Crystal Lake, Illinois? What’s your favorite thing to order? Tell us in the comments! Start planning your trip by checking out the Pots and Pies Bakery website and the Pots and Pies Bakery Facebook page. After grabbing a snack at the bakery, consider heading to this secret tropical beach in Crystal Lake for a gorgeous day in the sun!

OnlyInYourState may earn compensation through affiliate links in this article. As an Amazon Associate, we earn from qualifying purchases.

Related Articles

Explore Illinois

Featured Addresses
Pots and Pies Bakery, 67 E Woodstock St, Crystal Lake, IL 60014, USA