Whether it is a donut, Danish, or even a cookie that you are craving, Carsten’s Bakery in Idaho Falls is the place to go. This bakery has been serving some of the best homemade pastries for decades, and each item is so good, locals just can’t seem to get enough. You’ll want to see for yourself why this small shop is one of the most popular bakeries in southeastern Idaho.

Carsten’s Bakery is an unassuming shop in downtown Idaho Falls. This is the kind of place you know is special the minute you walk through its front door.
Google Maps
Willi and Shannon Carstens opened this family-owned bakery in 1968. Willi grew up in Germany during the 1930s and '40s, and at the young age of 16, he knew he wanted to be a baker. He even worked as a baker’s apprentice for three years before moving to America.
Carstens' Bakery/Facebook
As you walk inside this German-influenced bakery, all of your senses will tingle. This bakery certainly has a nostalgic vibe to it, and you’ll feel welcome the minute you arrive.
Elahe Javadi/Google
While the atmosphere is certainly inviting and friendly, it is the homemade pastries that keep locals coming back for more.
Casten’s Bakery/Google

Related Stories

These 13 Chocolate Shops In Idaho Will Make Your Sweet Tooth Explode

These 13 Chocolate Shops In Idaho Will Make Your Sweet Tooth Explode

 With Dozens Of Flavors, The Homemade Ice Cream At This Small Town Shop In Idaho Is Melt In Your Mouth Good

With Dozens Of Flavors, The Homemade Ice Cream At This Small Town Shop In Idaho Is Melt In Your Mouth Good

 You Can Still Order The Original 1961 Ice Cream Recipe At This Old School Eatery In Idaho

You Can Still Order The Original 1961 Ice Cream Recipe At This Old School Eatery In Idaho
The donuts are some of the most popular items here, and you’ll find quite a selection ranging from traditional glazed donuts to seasonal options like pumpkin spice sugar donuts.
Carstens' Bakery/Facebook
The shelves are also filled with homemade Danish pastries that are large and packed with filling. You’ll want to visit multiple times to try each and every flavor.
Casten’s Bakery/Google
Don't forget to grab some cookies, a loaf of bread, and a few dozen rolls to take home with you. Each baked good is prepared to perfection, and you'll taste the difference in every bite.
Carstens' Bakery/Facebook
And, if you are craving that perfect pick-me-up or a tasty dessert, try a cream puff or even a slice of pie.
Carstens' Bakery/Facebook
No matter what baked good you are craving, you’ll likely find it at Carsten’s Bakery in Idaho Falls. After just one visit, you’ll see why locals consider it one of the best bakeries in southeastern Idaho.
Carstens' Bakery/Facebook

Have you been to Carsten’s Bakery in Idaho Falls? If so, what are your favorite pastries sold here? Let us know in the comments! You can learn more about this bakery, including its hours and unique menu items, on its Facebook page.

Another must-visit bakery in Idaho is Stacey Cakes, located up north in McCall. This is an unassuming place to eat, but you will be craving the food days after you’ve left.

OnlyInYourState may earn compensation through affiliate links in this article. As an Amazon Associate, we earn from qualifying purchases.

Related Articles

Explore Idaho

Featured Addresses
243 Cliff St, Idaho Falls, ID 83402, USA