Idaho is full of creepy legends. There are some, like the Water Babies of Massacre Rocks, that send chills down our spine. But, there are others, like Sharlie, the Payette Lake Monster, that bring a smile to our faces. Located at one of Idaho’s largest lakes is one of the scariest, most fascinating legends in the Gem State — the Vanishing Paddler on Lake Pend Oreille.

Related Stories

The Brewery In Idaho That Features A Menu Full Of Unique Food Items

The Brewery In Idaho That Features A Menu Full Of Unique Food Items

A Peaceful Escape Can Be Found Along This Year-Round Mountain Trail In Idaho

A Peaceful Escape Can Be Found Along This Year-Round Mountain Trail In Idaho

It's An Epic Outdoor Adventure At Hot Springs Campground In Idaho

It's An Epic Outdoor Adventure At Hot Springs Campground In Idaho

What do you believe? Do you believe there is a creature living in this lake? Have you ever seen anything suspicious when visiting Lake Pend Oreille? We’d love to hear your thoughts in the comments.

No matter whether you believe this fascinating legend or not, I recommend you spend some time at Lake Pend Oreille in northern Idaho. While you are there, take a drive down the Pend Oreille Scenic Byway and book a stay in a comfortable vacation rental.

OnlyInYourState may earn compensation through affiliate links in this article. As an Amazon Associate, we earn from qualifying purchases.