Nothing hits the spot quite like a homemade piece of pie. However, it can be challenging trying to find it! This little cafe may not look like much, but they are famous among locals for their delicious pie. There’s a reason this place has been around since 1927. Not only is their home-style cooking to die for, but their pie is simply heavenly. Next time you find yourself with a pie craving, be sure to stop by this quaint little diner in Heyburn. Take a look.

Located off of I-84, Connor's Cafe looks like your average roadside diner. If you're ever traveling on this part of the freeway, you absolutely must make a stop here. Something delicious awaits you inside.
Anthony Holdier/GoogleMaps
The family-run cafe was originally located in Montana when it opened in 1927. They made the move to their current location in 1965. This place has been around for a long, long time. You'll understand why once you get a taste of their food.
Scott LePage/GoogleMaps
The casual restaurant welcomes both locals and travelers with hot, homemade food. They pride themselves in making everything from scratch—not frozen.
Roger Rodrz/GoogleMaps

Related Stories

A Dessert-Only Restaurant Just Opened Up In Idaho And It's Just As Heavenly As It Sounds

A Dessert-Only Restaurant Just Opened Up In Idaho And It's Just As Heavenly As It Sounds

 This Hidden Ice Cream Stand In Idaho Is To Die For And You'll Want To Find It

This Hidden Ice Cream Stand In Idaho Is To Die For And You'll Want To Find It

 This Sugary-Sweet Ice Cream Shop In Idaho Serves Enormous Portions You’ll Love

This Sugary-Sweet Ice Cream Shop In Idaho Serves Enormous Portions You’ll Love
However, their crown jewel has got to be their homemade pies. With flaky and crispy crusts containing a juicy filling, they are absolutely mouthwatering.
SLNColor/TripAdvisor
It's hard to find scrumptious homemade pie like this. Order a slice to enjoy right away and then take a whole pie to-go with you! Hint: the Oatmeal Pie is a local favorite.
Todd Graham/GoogleMaps
Don't be fooled by the cafe's "truck stop" location. This delightful little eatery contains some seriously good eats, including the best pie in southern Idaho.
Ahems/TripAdvisor
You'll find Connor's Cafe at 339 S 600 W, Heyburn, ID 83336. They are open seven days a week from 6:00 am to 9:00 pm.

Have you been to Connor’s Cafe? Tell us about your favorite place to grab some pie in the comments. And don’t forget to check out this other epic pie restaurant in Idaho.

OnlyInYourState may earn compensation through affiliate links in this article. As an Amazon Associate, we earn from qualifying purchases.

Related Articles

Explore Idaho