Whether you are dining at a fancy Italian bistro or simply grabbing a slice from the pizzeria down the street, everyone loves a good slice of pizza. Hawaii isn’t necessarily known for their delicious Italian food, but luckily for us, there are still a few excellent pizzerias across the islands to satisfy that ever-present pizza craving, including this unassuming gem in Lahaina.

Housed in a once-abandoned plantation-style house, Prison Street Pizza may look modest from the exterior, but after just one bite of their scrumptious pies, you’ll be hooked.
Prison Street Pizza/Facebook
Serving up freshly made, thin-crust pizzas with all of your favorite toppings — whether you’re a meat lover or prefer all things veggie — there’s no better place for a casual meal with friends or family than Prison Street Pizza.
Prison Street Pizza/Facebook
With more than 40 years in the pizza business, the owners sure know how to make a killer, made-from-scratch, New Jersey-style pizza sure to satisfy all of your cravings.
Prison Street Pizza/Facebook
Choose from a variety of specialty pizzas, like Grandma’s pizza made with alfredo sauce, chicken breast, spinach, garlic, and mozzarella cheese…
Prison Street Pizza/Facebook

Related Stories

Make Your Own Hawaiian-Style Pizza In A Kiawe-Fired Brick Oven At Pounders Restaurant

Make Your Own Hawaiian-Style Pizza In A Kiawe-Fired Brick Oven At Pounders Restaurant

 The Pizzas Served At The Off-The-Beaten-Path Ohelo Cafe In Hawaii Are To Die For

The Pizzas Served At The Off-The-Beaten-Path Ohelo Cafe In Hawaii Are To Die For

 The Sourdough Waffles And Pizza Served At Wicked HI Cafe In Hawaii Are As Delicious As Can Be

The Sourdough Waffles And Pizza Served At Wicked HI Cafe In Hawaii Are As Delicious As Can Be
...or build your own pizza from their nearly two dozen topping offerings. Which one of these delicious pizzas ready to get cooked would you choose?
Prison Street Pizza/Facebook
Pizza isn’t the only thing you’ll find on the menu here, though: you can choose from a mouthwatering variety of salads, subs, appetizers, and entrees — from calzones to mozzarella sticks and chicken parmesan sandwiches.
Prison Street Pizza/Website
With a laid-back atmosphere, melt-in-your-mouth pizzas, and a variety of beers to choose from, it’d be a criminal offense not to visit Prison Street Pizza at least once.
Prison Street Pizza/Facebook
So, what are you waiting for? This is one prison (read: pizzeria) you'll want to visit again and again.
Prison Street Pizza/Facebook

Prison Street Pizza is located at 133 Prison St., Lahaina, HI 96761, and is open daily from 10 a.m. to 10 p.m. For more information, visit their website or follow them on Facebook.

Have you ever been to this unique Hawaii pizzeria? What’s your favorite pizza topping? Share your opinions in the comments below, then click here to discover one of our other favorite Lahaina restaurants, Star Noodle.

OnlyInYourState may earn compensation through affiliate links in this article. As an Amazon Associate, we earn from qualifying purchases.

Related Articles

Explore Hawaii