Florida is well-known for having the best Key Lime pie in all the land. I mean, heck, there is an entire festival dedicated to the best key lime pie in Florida. But in case you’re not looking to do the whole shebang and prefer to just enjoy a slice of that creamy, tart, sugary goodness on a warm day, then we have the perfect bakery to stop by.

Good things come in small packages—which is why this tiny bakeshop in Key West has some really good things to offer up to visitors.
Facebook Key Lime Pie Bakery
The Key Lime pie from Key Lime Pie Bakery is an absolute must the next time you’re down south, because really, it’s hard to find Key Lime pie made quite like this.
TripAdvisor management
Locally owned and operated, this original bakeshop specializes in fresh baked Key Lime pie every single day.
TripAdvisor Damien S.
But what’s more, is that this small little bakeshop was one of the original bake shops for Key Lime pie in the state—which means you’re definitely getting the best of the best.
TripAdvisor hansulricha

Related Stories

The Taco & Ice Cream Parlor In Florida Is Everything You Never Knew You Needed

The Taco & Ice Cream Parlor In Florida Is Everything You Never Knew You Needed

 The Breads From This Florida Bakery Take 72-Hours To Become Heaven On Earth

The Breads From This Florida Bakery Take 72-Hours To Become Heaven On Earth

 This Half-Pound Cookie In Florida Has Been An Award-Winning Indulgence

This Half-Pound Cookie In Florida Has Been An Award-Winning Indulgence
For those visiting the area in search of the perfect slice of Key Lime pie, this is the place to visit—and while it may be busy, the wait is always worth it.
TripAdvisor Damien S.
The texture of the filling of the pie is light and fluffy, but also smooth on your tongue. Plus you’ll find the perfect balance of tart and sweet.
TripAdvisor octrekster
Some might even call this slice of pie from Key Lime Pie Bakery a perfect piece.
TripAdvisor James H.
Visit the shop and explore the other gifts and goods available—you can even take home some of the sweets and treats offered throughout the store.
TripAdvisor mr_shope_ful
So the next time you’re looking for that tangy, sweet, slide-your-fork-right-through-to-the-crust slice of Key Lime pie, make sure this bakeshop is on your agenda.
TripAdvisor Damien S.

Who’s ready for dessert?! The address for the original Key Lime Pie Bakery is 412 Greene St, Key West, FL 33040. The hours are Monday through Friday from 6:30 a.m. to 11 p.m., and Saturday and Sunday from 8 a.m. to 11 p.m. To find out more, visit the website or Facebook Page.

OnlyInYourState may earn compensation through affiliate links in this article. As an Amazon Associate, we earn from qualifying purchases.

Related Articles

Explore Florida