You know those really special homemade feasts that most of us only get to enjoy during the holidays? At this restaurant in Sarasota, you can have a meal like that any time of year. Bring your appetite, because you’ll want to stuff your face at this all you can eat Amish restaurant in Florida.

Der Dutchman is located at 3713 Bahia Vista Street in Sarasota, near the Amish community of Pinecraft.
Yelp/Marqus R.
That's right, Florida has an Amish community! And that's great for the rest of us, too, because Amish restaurants are famous for cooking the best comfort food in the world.
Yelp/Harlan M.
At Der Dutchman in Florida, you'll find it all: Fried and roasted chicken, mashed potatoes with gravy, ham, meatloaf, roast beef, mac 'n' cheese, and much, much more, all made from scratch daily.
TripAdvisor / drmikenyc
Even better, Der Dutchman offers an all-you-can-eat buffet, so you can try a little of everything.
TripAdvisor/drmikenyc

Related Stories

You Can Watch Planes Land At High Jackers Restaurant, An Underrated Restaurant In Florida

You Can Watch Planes Land At High Jackers Restaurant, An Underrated Restaurant In Florida

 This Beautiful Intracoastal Restaurant, Billy’s Stone Crab In Florida, Offers Waterfront Dining

This Beautiful Intracoastal Restaurant, Billy’s Stone Crab In Florida, Offers Waterfront Dining

 Enjoy Gorgeous Views At Cap's On The Water, A Spectacular Restaurant In Florida

Enjoy Gorgeous Views At Cap's On The Water, A Spectacular Restaurant In Florida
Although you might not expect it among all of these tasty comfort foods, you can also find some good healthy options on the menu. If you go for the buffet, check out the salad bar for the usual fresh veggies as well as some unique Amish options you probably haven't tried before.
TripAdvisor/travelers966
Of course, it wouldn't be a real feast without dessert. Just looking at these pies and cakes will make your mouth water.
TripAdvisor/caper9898
On your way out, stop by the bakery on the first floor and choose from a wide array of delicious homemade sweets. There is also a selection of savory goods, including cheese and sausages.
TripAdvidor/caper9898
You can also head upstairs to the large gift shop, which has something for everyone. It's a really fun place to browse, and it adds to the whole experience.
TripAdvisor/caper9898
Der Dutchman is the perfect place to go with a large group of people, as it will satisfy all different taste buds and appetites. Those with a serious sweet tooth will be happy, too! Der Dutchman is open for breakfast, lunch, and dinner.

 

Have you been to this all you can eat Amish restaurant in Florida? Where’s your favorite place to go for an epic feast in the Sunshine State? Share your thoughts with us in the comments below! And if you know another must-visit eatery, nominate it for a chance to be featured.

For another incredible dining experience, visit this seafood restaurant in the middle of the Florida everglades.

OnlyInYourState may earn compensation through affiliate links in this article. As an Amazon Associate, we earn from qualifying purchases.

More to Explore

all you can eat Amish restaurant in Florida

Elisa Regulski | July 27, 2020

What are the best Amish restaurants in Florida?

Der Dutchman isn’t the only Amish restaurant in Florida. For more home-cooked goodness, visit Yoder's Restaurant & Amish Village in Sarasota. This old-fashioned eatery is known for crafting mouthwatering meals you can’t stop thinking about. Be sure to save room for dessert! Their handcrafted pies are absolutely magical.

What are the best all you can eat restaurants in Florida?

Meat lovers will adore The Knife in Orlando. This eatery is known for its never ending supply of grilled meats. There’s a reason why people think it’s the best all you can eat restaurant in Florida! Bring your appetite and devour some scrumptious meals. If it’s seafood you’re after, visit Whale Harbor Restaurant in Islamorada. This famous restaurant has all of the delicious seafood dishes you crave.

What are the best comfort food restaurants in Florida?

For some of the best comfort food in Florida, head over to 4th Street Fillin Station in Cocoa Beach. This colorful eatery serves scrumptious tacos, delicious brunch dishes, and tons of tasty beer. You’ll love their outdoor dining area. It’s the perfect place to gather with friends. For more tasty eats, visit MAC’d Out in Winter Garden. This mac and cheese restaurant puts exciting spins on the classic childhood dish. Here, you’ll find chicken and waffle mac, Bourbon BBQ mac, and even seafood mac with scallops. You’ve never had mac and cheese like this before!

Related Articles

Explore Florida

Featured Addresses
Der Dutchman, 3713 Bahia Vista St, Sarasota, FL 34232, USA