People are impressed by size, and huge restaurants (and parks, and stores) often get a lot of press. It’s easy to be blown away by a sprawling eatery that has a massive menu and can serve dozens of guests. Bigger isn’t always better, though, and if you’re looking for a small restaurant in Connecticut, you’ll love the homey pub we have featured for you today. The Horseshoe Cafe is tucked away in downtown Southport, CT, and this little spot is tiny. It can only serve a handful of guests at a time. However, don’t let that stop you from popping inside. This small pub in Southport, CT serves up delicious food, an array of cold brews, and even hosts live music.

"The Shoe," as the little bar is affectionately nicknamed, has a long history. The restaurant opened up in 1934 and has been in the same family since 1957.
Tassilo Kubitz/Google Reviews
The building was constructed around 1916 and was originally a farrier shop, hence the name "Horseshoe Cafe."
Bob Hyland/Google Reviews
You'll see horse-themed decor throughout the restaurant.
This spot is the quintessential local pub.
Jesse Seymour/Google Reviews
Walk in here and it'll feel like you stepped onto the set of Cheers. This place is a classic gem that hasn't changed in years, and it feels like everyone's a regular. Live music is played by local acts on Mondays, giving you a fun soundtrack to your meal.

Related Stories

The Small-Town Restaurant In Connecticut That Is Worth A Visit From Anywhere In The State

The Small-Town Restaurant In Connecticut That Is Worth A Visit From Anywhere In The State

 Dig Into Made-From-Scratch Comfort Food At This Neighborhood Restaurant In Connecticut

Dig Into Made-From-Scratch Comfort Food At This Neighborhood Restaurant In Connecticut

 Indulge In Good, Old-Fashioned Comfort Food At The Shed In Connecticut, Coming Spring 2024

Indulge In Good, Old-Fashioned Comfort Food At The Shed In Connecticut, Coming Spring 2024
Of course, you can choose from a menu of delicious drinks, with wine, beer, and more on tap.
horseshoecafesouthport/Instagram
However, there's also a big menu full of classic bar dishes, like New York-style pizza, burgers, and sandwiches.
David Rodriguez/Google Reviews
There are even seasonal specials like lobster rolls (this is New England, after all!).
horseshoecafesouthport/Instagram
Next time you're looking for a surprisingly tasty meal in a compact, cozy atmosphere, look no further than the historic Horseshoe Cafe in Southport, CT.
David Rodriguez/Google Reviews

For more information about this small pub in Southport, CT, including a full menu and current specials, check out The Horseshoe Cafe website or The Horseshoe Cafe Facebook page.

Looking for the perfect place to stay in Southport, CT? Check out Delamar Southport: it’s centrally-located and is so close to multiple beaches. This is a charming small town to visit, and it’s also home to one of Connecticut’s best thrift stores.

OnlyInYourState may earn compensation through affiliate links in this article. As an Amazon Associate, we earn from qualifying purchases.

Related Articles

Explore Connecticut

Featured Addresses
Horseshoe Cafe, 355 Pequot Ave, Southport, CT 06890, USA