The Old Mystic area in Connecticut is a charming little historic district that will make you feel like you stepped back in time. One beloved shop right in the very center of Old Mystic is the aptly-named Old Mystic General Store. This place perfectly embodies the feeling of nostalgia you get from being in a historic place like Old Mystic.

Editor’s Note: Unfortunately, since the time of publication, this general store has closed.

Old Mystic is a place that preserves its history. There's been a general store at this location in town since 1790!
Jerry Brisson/Google Maps
The general store currently operating here is more of a restaurant than a traditional general store like you may be used to. However, they still carry a few general items and grocery store goods.
Sindi Mannochi/Google Maps
They've also got an array of Connecticut-themed items from local vendors. Photos, postcards, art, and crafts: these all make great souvenirs for visitors!
The Old Mystic Country Store featuring Papa Tony's Pizza/Facebook

Related Stories

Creations Is A Delightful Gift Shop With A Purpose In Connecticut

Creations Is A Delightful Gift Shop With A Purpose In Connecticut

 The Homemade Goods From This Amish Store In Connecticut Are Worth The Drive To Get Them

The Homemade Goods From This Amish Store In Connecticut Are Worth The Drive To Get Them

 Spend The Day Exploring These Country Stores In Connecticut

Spend The Day Exploring These Country Stores In Connecticut
Many stop by and grab a bite to eat here. Their sandwiches and grinders are very popular. This is an under-the-radar gem that's a little less crowded than some of the restaurants in Mystic's main street area.
Joseph Normand/Google Maps
Old Mystic also has a cabinet with various baked goods for sale, in case you're in the mood for something sweet.
Richard Savino/Google Maps
Old Mystic Country Store's made quite the name for itself with their delicious Papa Tony's Pizza. Many claim it's the best in Connecticut!
The Old Mystic Country Store featuring Papa Tony's Pizza/Facebook
Sadly, their kitchen had some venting issues and they had to stop baking pizza at the store location. However, they now have a mobile brick oven. The oven travels throughout Connecticut at various events, so you can still enjoy the wood-fired taste of Papa Tony's Pizza, even if it's not actually at the Old Mystic Country Store.

Have you been to the Old Mystic Country Store in Connecticut? Share your experiences in the comments!

For more information about the Old Mystic Country Store or to see where they’ll be parking the mobile pizza oven next, check out their Facebook. If you’d like to check out another old general store in Connecticut, look into the Colebrook Store in Colebrook. It’s been around since 1812!

OnlyInYourState may earn compensation through affiliate links in this article. As an Amazon Associate, we earn from qualifying purchases.

Related Articles

Explore Connecticut

Featured Addresses
Old Mystic Country Store, 47 Main St, Old Mystic, CT 06372, USA