As we move closer to the summer months, the time grows more opportune to share stories around the campfire. Few stories invoke chills like tales of true crime, and one of the most infamous serial killers in history chose Cleveland as the backdrop for their brutal slayings. Its proximity to home will startle you.

In the 1930s, life in the United States was undeniably tough.
Dorothea Lange/Wikimedia Commons
In the midst of the Great Depression, Americans suffered financially. Lifestyles suffered as well, and as the ability to support oneself and one's family diminished, shanty towns appeared across the country.
The landscape of Cleveland changed in response to the Depression.
U.S. National Archives and Records Administration/Wikimedia Commons
Cleveland's poorer neighborhoods soon began creating their own shantytowns, but none were as dangerous as the Kingsbury Run neighborhood.
It was in Kingsbury Run that a series of disturbing murders took place.
Joseph E. Cole/Cleveland Press Collections Identifier torso065r:
Known as the Torso Murders, these bone-chilling slayers were identifiable by the killer's affinity for dismemberment. Victims were beheaded and often brutally dismembered. Some victims appear to have been exposed to some sort of chemical agent as well.
The disturbing slayings took place between 1935 and 1938, but mystery and uncertainty surround the case.
Gargantuen/Wikimedia Commons
Twelve victims were officially linked to the case, though modern studies theorize that the number of victims may actually be nearly double that. Most of the victims' identities were never determined.
Edward W. Andrassy was the first victim to be officially identified.
Edward W. Andrassy/Wikimedia Commons
It was not uncommon to find Andrassy in the rougher regions of the Kingsbury Run area, and he had actually been arrested on several occasions related to drunkenness and brawling. He was identified by his fingerprints.
All of the victims came from the lower levels of society and most were easy targets whose absence went largely unnoticed.
Gargantuen/Wikimedia Commons
Another victim, Florence Polillo, did not have a positive reputation. Though she was a waitress by day, her nighttime profession involved cavorting with more unfavorable individuals. Her body was found in pieces behind the Hart Manufacturing Plant on East 20th, though her head was never recovered.
The really disturbing piece of the story is that despite the brutality of the murders, the killer was never caught.
Joseph E. Cole/Cleveland Press Collections Identifier torso006
Elliot Ness was the Public Safety Director of Cleveland at the time, and though he had little to do with the investigation, he and his team were taunted by a cocky killer. The murderer went so far as to place human remains near Ness' office in City Hall.

Related Stories

The Magnificent Countryside Airbnb Near Cleveland That Is Perfect For A Spring Retreat

The Magnificent Countryside Airbnb Near Cleveland That Is Perfect For A Spring Retreat

 This Enchanting Garden Restaurant In Cleveland Will Transport You To Another World

This Enchanting Garden Restaurant In Cleveland Will Transport You To Another World

 Huge Things Actually Happened In These 5 Small Towns Near Cleveland

Huge Things Actually Happened In These 5 Small Towns Near Cleveland
It is possible that several other unexplained deaths could be linked to the serial killings.
Joseph E. Cole/Cleveland Press Collections Identifier torso038
The "Lady of the Lake," an unidentified victim found in Lake Erie, has been suggested to be one of the Torso Murderer's victims. A series of dismembered bodies found in Pennsylvania have also been proposed to have been linked to the Cleveland slayings as well. Some have even suggested that the infamous Black Dahlia Murder was committed by this Cleveland killer.
Several suspects have been identified, but nobody has ever been formally charged.
Joseph E. Cole/Cleveland Press Collections Identifier torso049
Suspect Mike Borich (pictured above) was taken in for questioning. He, along with the likes of Francis E. Sweeney and Frank Dolezal, fit the profile of a seemingly sane man with a spectacular knowledge of anatomy or butchery.
The investigation into the Torso Murders, however, was overflowing with corruption.
Joseph E. Cole/Cleveland Press Collections Identifier torso028
Pictured here is the tub at 1908 Central Avenue, a site where suspect Frank Dolezal "confessed" to dismembering the body of victim Florence Pollilo. Frank Dolezal, by all accounts a healthy man, died in the Cuyahoga County jail under suspicious circumstances. In postmortem analysis, it was discovered that Dolezal had six broken ribs, an injury which his friends and family say was not preexisting. Many believe his confession was beaten out of him and that he actually had no connection to the case.
The most likely suspect Dr. Francis E. Sweeney, walked away free, thanks to his political ties.
Joseph E. Cole/Cleveland Press Collections Identifier torso059
Sweeney, a veteran of the first World War, was well-versed in the art of amputation. He was a field doctor during the war and performed many amputations and during the initial investigation, he failed an early polygraph test. However, he was related to Congressman Martin L. Sweeney, who also happened to be related to the investigating sheriff through marriage.
After the demolition of Kingsbury Run and an intensive investigation, the killings eventually ceased.
Joseph E. Cole/Cleveland Press Collections Identifier torso005
Some theorize that the 1950 murder of Robert Robertson, a brutal slaying and dismemberment on Davenport Avenue, may have been the killer's final victim, many years later.
Despite years of interest and intensive investigation, the killer remained anonymous and many of his victims remain unidentified.
Cuyahoga County Medical Examiner/Wikimedia Commons
Today, the murders that took place during Depression-era Cleveland still haunt the city.
Snake Oil Magazine/Flickr

Despite our impressive and colorful history, Cleveland has a dark side that continues to haunt locals to this day. Have you ever heard of this heinous crime?

If you love local lore, you’ll be fascinated by these creatures that purportedly haunt Greater Cleveland.

OnlyInYourState may earn compensation through affiliate links in this article. As an Amazon Associate, we earn from qualifying purchases.

Related Articles