The New York Restaurant In The Middle Of Nowhere That's So Worth The Journey

When it comes to New York’s restaurants, some of the best places you’ll ever eat in our state can be found in the most unsuspecting places. I recently spoke of one remote restaurant that will take you a million miles away from it all, and realized there was another dining destination in our state that was completely worth the journey it takes to get there. Already recognize this amazing place? If not, then let’s talk about this one flavorful restaurant that’s out in the middle of nowhere!

Lobster Roll/Yelp

susan n./Yelp

For many New Yorkers, Long Island feels like another world. All the way out past New York City and hundreds of miles away from the majority of our state, our northern residents are often skittish of this long drive. With that said, it's time to take an adventure because this one restaurant will have your mouth watering by the time you're done reading about.

How to get here: 1980 Montauk Highway Amagansett, NY 11930

Advertisement

Mark M./Yelp

Advertisement

Lobster Roll/Yelp

Frederick Terry and his father Richard Terry would buy the then clam shack and turn it into something truly iconic. Out by Napeague State Park, the restaurant is right amongst the beautiful sand dunes and gives you a taste of the island life.

Recognize this restaurant from somewhere? The Golden Globe Award Winning Showtime series The Affair frequently films here! If you're going to take a long journey out to this restaurant, it never hurts to check their official Facebook Page to double check that they're not closed for filming.

Related Stories

12 Under The Radar Restaurants In New York That Are Scrumdiddlyumptious

The Secluded Restaurant In New York With The Most Magical Surroundings

This New York Restaurant Is So Remote You've Probably Never Heard Of It

Lobster Roll/Yelp

Isabelle E./Yelp

With their now iconic LUNCH sign still outside of the restaurant, locals quickly began referring to the restaurant simply as Lunch! But don't let the nickname fool you, Lobster Roll Restaurant serves both lunch and dinner!

Visible on their main menu, their famous dish is served in two different ways and is made with a recipe that's been used for 50 years. You can either get the Hot Lobster Roll, featuring chunks of hot lobster and butter with toasted hot dog buns and homemade cole slaw. Or, you can try the Classic Lobster Roll, that is served cold with cole slaw and is great to pair up with some french fries!

Isabelle E./Yelp

Isabelle E./Yelp

While it's the lunch and dinner meals that draw in a crowd, there's nothing like topping off your meal with one of their homemade desserts! If you click here you can view the entire dessert menu, featuring ice cream, a variety of fruit pies, cupcakes and even chocolate chip cookies. Don't let your sweet tooth go to waste!

Have you been to this remote restaurant in New York? Is there a restaurant within our state that you’ll make a long drive for? If you’re suddenly feeling hungry and ready to try new restaurants, then you’ll want to read about these 12 Neighborhood Restaurants In New York With Food So Good You’ll Be Back For Seconds!