New Jersey is a pretty great pizza town, and the odds are you can find a great slice or pie anywhere you turn. Whether you want an old-fashioned corner slice topped with all the pepperoni you can handle, or a wood-fired pie topped with the best cheese and herbs, every town has something to satisfy. However, I can safely say I’ve never had anything like the over-the-top pies at Tony Boloney’s, a popular local chain with an original location in Atlantic City. Pizza toppings are getting more diverse all around the board lately, but these are definitely the wackiest pizzas in New Jersey. They’re putting anything and everything on these pies, letting the international influences take over and proving that the spirit of New Jersey has always been invention – and the offbeat and off-color sense of humor doesn’t hurt!

Tony Boloney's now has locations in Hoboken, Long Branch, Jersey City, and Margate, but the Atlantic City original is still the favorite thanks to its famous "Big Deck" with oceanfront views.
Reya on the Road/Google Local
The Jersey vibe is strong inside and out, and everything about this place is in-your-face.
Anna Regina Sarkozy/Google Local
The pizza selection is unparalleled, with something for every taste. Browse the selections - but some of the names are a little off-color, so mom and dad may want to take a look first!
Juliz Carroll/Google Local
Every pizza here has a little something extra. The Burrrrrata has a whole ball of ultra-rich burrata on every slice.
Tony Boloney's
The Jewish Cowboy has slow-smoked brisket and horseradish to go with the sauce and cheese.
Tony Boloney's

Related Stories

This Eclectic Restaurant In New Jersey Has Its Very Own Bakery

This Eclectic Restaurant In New Jersey Has Its Very Own Bakery

 Enjoy A Mouthwatering Pasta Flight At This Incredible New Jersey Restaurant

Enjoy A Mouthwatering Pasta Flight At This Incredible New Jersey Restaurant

 The Cozy Restaurant In New Jersey That’s Perfect For An Intimate Dinner

The Cozy Restaurant In New Jersey That’s Perfect For An Intimate Dinner
Looking for carbo overload? Consider the Heart Attack, which has buffalo chicken mac and cheese, ranch dressing, and smoked bacon.
Tony Boloney's
When you get into the international options, it gets even wilder. The Shogun Shadowboxer combines aged mozzarella with chili-fried chicken, black sesame, nori, and scallions.
Tony Boloney's
The Tikka tops your pizza with a creamy and spicy tikka masala sauce, plus paneer and green chutney.
Tony Boloney's
The most famous pizza at Tony Boloney's is probably the Taco Taco Taco, which...you guessed it, tops your pizza with mini-tacos and guac in the middle!
Tony Boloney's
The subs are just as wild. Sure, you can get a meatball or cheesesteak, but the adventurous will want to dig into the Crabby Chicken Killer, which has jumbo lump crab, grilled chicken, bayou butter, and mozzarella.
Tony Boloney's
Not even the fries are safe from being topped with crazy stuff! The loaded fries at Tony Boloney's are the stuff of legend, and come in seven varieties.
Nick Bohenko/Google Local

Have you eaten the wackiest pizzas in New Jersey at Tony Boloney’s? Tell us your favorite pies in the comments section! You can visit the official Tony Boloney’s website for the full menu and all the locations, and keep an eye on Tony Boloney’s Facebook page for the latest announcements! While you’re in Atlantic City, would the day really be complete without a trip down the city’s record-setting boardwalk?

OnlyInYourState may earn compensation through affiliate links in this article. As an Amazon Associate, we earn from qualifying purchases.

Related Articles

Explore New Jersey

Featured Addresses
Tony Boloney's Atlantic City, 300 Oriental Ave, Atlantic City, NJ 08401, USA