Sometimes the best hidden gems are found in the tiniest of towns. The tiny New Mexico town is called Pie Town, and it is aptly named because it has some of the best pies you will ever taste. Pie Town is a bit of a hippie, artist, and biker enclave, as it’s been for decades, and the people are as friendly as can be. They love it when people stop in for a slice of their town’s namesake treat. Welcome to Pie-O-Neer Pies, home of the best pies in New Mexico!

The Old West style exterior fits right in with the high desert surroundings, and is part of the rustic charm of this area.
Dan C/TripAdvisor
A sign on the front of the building educates visitors about the history of this place . It’s safe to say that the quality has never faltered when it comes to the pies.
Nicole A/TripAdvisor
When you walk in, you’ll be greeted by the lovely smell of the pies, and the rustic and charming decorations are reminiscent of Route 66, which is only about an hour north of here.
Alejandro Bencomo/Google Maps

Related Stories

This Mountaintop Country Store In New Mexico Sells The Most Amazing Homemade Fudge You'll Ever Try

This Mountaintop Country Store In New Mexico Sells The Most Amazing Homemade Fudge You'll Ever Try

 People Are Going Crazy Over The Handmade Donuts At This New Mexico Bakery

People Are Going Crazy Over The Handmade Donuts At This New Mexico Bakery

 The Outrageous Milkshake Bar In New Mexico That’s Piled High With Goodness

The Outrageous Milkshake Bar In New Mexico That’s Piled High With Goodness
There are so many different kinds of pies to choose from. You can get them whole or by the slice, and can even get them a la mode! Everyone here is so friendly, it’s hard to tell what is sweeter, the people or the pies.
Pauline Bacod/Google Maps
Pie-O-Neer gets pretty creative with its pies. Apple pie with green chilis and pine nuts? Yes, please! Sweet and spicy are a great flavor combination. Of course, in New Mexico, everything comes with chilis. Restaurants will often simply ask, “Green or red?” when you order food to find out what kind of chilis you prefer.
Pie-O-Neer PIES/Google Maps
This could be your view, tucking into these scrumptious, sweet, gooey pies with light, flaky, buttery crusts. Wipe off your mouth and get in the car right now! The pies, they beckon you!
Pookybun p/TripAdvisor

Pie-O-Neer Pies has varying hours, so make sure to check with them to make sure they’re open before you head over. If they are, try to get there early because they might sell out quickly! Best of all, they don’t use much sugar, there are no preservatives, and they can accommodate vegan and gluten-free diets. Places like this are one of the many reasons why New Mexico is so underrated. If you have any favorite places in New Mexico, head on over to the comments and let us know about them!

OnlyInYourState may earn compensation through affiliate links in this article. As an Amazon Associate, we earn from qualifying purchases.

Related Articles

Explore New Mexico

Featured Addresses
5613 US-60, Pie Town, NM 87827, USA