Hidden in small-town Indiana is a little hole-in-the-wall mom-and-pop steakhouse that’s so good, Hoosiers flock to it from all over the state just to experience it. The restaurant itself – Shorty’s Steakhouse, in Garrett, Indiana – isn’t even terribly large; it’s an intimate, small little place that’s sure to leave you not just stuffed but incredibly pleased with your meal, too. Come to this small steakhouse in Indiana and enjoy one of the best meals you’ve ever had; after all, there’s a reason this is easily one of our favorite steakhouses in Indiana.

The sign outside lets you know you've arrived, and you know what that means: you're in for a downright delicious time.
Shorty’s Steakhouse
Instant360 888.266.5360 (instant360)/Google
Shorty's isn't a gigantic place; it's definitely the epitome of a "hole in the wall", but we strongly believe that this only adds to its charm.
Inside, it's warm and cozy, the perfect place to unbutton the top button on your jeans and prepare to eat yourself silly.
Shorty's Steakhouse/Facebook
And trust us, you'll want to - there's not a single thing on the menu we think you won't like. Everything is masterfully prepared, and it's obvious from the first bite why Shorty's is THE place to be on a Friday night in small-town Indiana.
Enjoy your favorite cuts of steak - whatever they may be - and indulge in some truly delectable sides.
Shorty's Steakhouse/Facebook
If you had to ask us to describe the steaks at Shorty's in three words, we'd probably say something like juicy, savory, and robust. We're a bit of a steak snob ourselves, so when we say Shorty's delivers when it comes to the perfect filet, we absolutely mean it.

Related Stories

Feast On Fried Fish At This Unassuming But Amazing Roadside Stop In Indiana

Feast On Fried Fish At This Unassuming But Amazing Roadside Stop In Indiana

 Enjoy An Endless, Enormous Buffet At The Journey In Indiana

Enjoy An Endless, Enormous Buffet At The Journey In Indiana

 There's A Delicious Steakhouse Hiding Inside This Old Indiana Stable That's Begging For A Visit

There's A Delicious Steakhouse Hiding Inside This Old Indiana Stable That's Begging For A Visit
Currently, the restaurant is open every day for dinner, but the hours may vary, so be sure to check the website and Facebook page below for any changes in the hours of operation.
Shorty’s Steakhouse
Shorty's Steakhouse/Facebook
Because Shorty's is such a popular, must-visit local restaurant, reservations are strongly recommended to ensure you get a table.
If you would like a light meal, we recommend dishes that blew us away like the Alaskan salmon or a 6-ounce filet mignon.
Shorty's Steakhouse/Facebook
But if you're hungry, then opt for a larger portion (definitely the "unbutton that top button" type of large). They include cooked-to-perfection crown jewels like the pasta primavera, the 12-ounce ribeye, ahi tuna, jumbo shrimp, and SO much more.
The drinks menu is also not to be missed - heck, nothing here is to be missed.
Shorty's Steakhouse/Facebook
We guess you'll have to visit a few more times to make sure you try everything eventually!

Want more food in Indiana? Watch this YouTube video by Around The World In One Day for some of the best restaurants in our state.

For the most up-to-date hours and menu, be sure to check out the official Shorty’s Steakhouse website. And for the latest specials, follow Shorty’s on Facebook.

While you’re in the area, check out this website for things to do in Garrett, Indiana.

OnlyInYourState may earn compensation through affiliate links in this article. As an Amazon Associate, we earn from qualifying purchases.

More to Explore

BEST STEAKHOUSES IN INDIANA & RELATED INFO

Melanie J. | July 28, 2023

What are some of the best steakhouses in Indiana?

When it comes to steaks, Shorty’s is at the top of my list as one of the best steakhouses in Indiana. But here are 10 more steakhouses in Indiana that are worthy of mentioning:

  • St. Elmo Steak House, Indianapolis
  • Fogo de Chão Brazilian Steakhouse, Indianapolis
  • Mountain Jacks Steakhouse, Lafayette
  • Eddie Merlot's, Indianapolis
  • Anthony’s Chophouse, Carmel
  • Stables Steakhouse, Terre Haute
  • Harry & Izzy's, Indianapolis
  • Cast Iron Steak House, Jeffersonville
  • Kelsey's Steak & Seafood, Valparaiso
  • Baker Street Steakhouse, Fort Wayne


While many of the best steakhouses are in Indianapolis, small towns have quite a few spots that are worth trying. Check out this article with some small town steakhouses in Indiana that belong on your list. 

What are some of the best restaurants in Indiana?

If you’re not a fan of steak and are searching for the best restaurants in Indiana, here are a few that we recommend:

  • The Vine, Elkhart
  • Big Hoffa's Smokehouse, Westfield
  • Mama Carolla's, Indianapolis
  • Livery, Indianapolis
  • Rick's Café Boatyard, Indianapolis
  • Kuma's Corner, Indianapolis
  • Willie's Sports Café, Lawrenceburg
  • The Rathskeller, Indianapolis
  • Flamme Burger Keystone, Indianapolis
  • Das Dutchman Essenhaus, Middlebury


Here’s an article with a list featuring more best restaurants in Indiana.

What are some of the best BBQ restaurants in Indiana?

Us Hoosiers know a little bit about BBQ, and here are some of the best BBQ restaurants in Indiana that are a must-visit:

  • Big Hoffa's Smokehouse, Westfield
  • Ben's BBQ Shack, Westfield
  • Jefferson Street Barbecue, Converse
  • Big JT's Craft BBQ, Columbus
  • Hank's Smoked Briskets, Indianapolis
  • Rusted Silo Southern BBQ & Brew House, Lizton
  • Squealers Award Winning Barbeque, Indianapolis
  • Bo Doogie's BBQ, Auburn
  • Hickory Hillz BBQ, Edinburgh
  • The Backroads BBQ, Lebanon
  • Firehouse BBQ and Blues, Richmond
  • Now That's Bar-B-Que!, Indianapolis


Be sure to read our previous article highlighting more of the best BBQ restaurants in Indiana.

Related Articles

Explore Indiana

Featured Addresses
127 N Randolph St, Garrett, IN 46738, USA