Oklahoma is home to its fair share of top-shelf steakhouses. From Mahogany Prime Steak House in Tulsa to Cattleman’s Steakhouse in Oklahoma City and numerous others throughout the Sooner State, there are some amazing steaks in the Sooner State. We think, however, we may have found the best one, hidden away in a back alley. Rusty Barrell Supper Club opened for business in 1974 and has been in the same location ever since. Located in Ponca City, Rusty Barrell Supper Club is hidden in plain sight and is a throwback to prohibition-era speakeasies. Still today, you enter in a side alley and ring the bell to be buzzed in. They are known for two things: great steaks and the best salad bar you have ever tasted. Keep scrolling to read more.

Rusty Barrell Supper Club is located at 2005 North 14th Street in Ponca City and has been serving up some of the best steaks in Oklahoma for almost 50 years.  
Facebook/bestlittlesteakhouseinoklahoma
Once inside, you will be reminded of the steakhouse glory days of the 1970s but with a modern facelift. This is a unique dining experience that should not be missed. 
Facebook/bestlittlesteakhouseinoklahoma
Many patrons believe this is their favorite salad bar. With loads of farm-fresh options, it is no wonder why people rave about it.
Facebook/bestlittlesteakhouseinoklahoma

Related Stories

A Night Out At Maggie's Music Box, A Music Venue, Rum Bar And Cantina In Oklahoma, Is Infinitely More Fun

A Night Out At Maggie's Music Box, A Music Venue, Rum Bar And Cantina In Oklahoma, Is Infinitely More Fun

 Grab A New Book, Yummy Treat, Or Drink As You Unwind At Whirlwind Book Bar In Oklahoma

Grab A New Book, Yummy Treat, Or Drink As You Unwind At Whirlwind Book Bar In Oklahoma

 The Entire Country Needs To Visit Broadway 10 Bar & Chophouse, An Urban Steakhouse In Oklahoma

The Entire Country Needs To Visit Broadway 10 Bar & Chophouse, An Urban Steakhouse In Oklahoma
Sautéed mushrooms and grilled asparagus pair perfectly with their house special 16-ounce ribeye. All their steaks are aged for 21 days and never frozen. 
Facebook/bestlittlesteakhouseinoklahoma
If you are in the mood for a cocktail we suggest the "Oklahoma Sunset" which consists of Malibu rum, creme de coconut, grenadine, and pineapple juice. Garnished with orange and cherries, this drink is heavenly. 
Facebook/bestlittlesteakhouseinoklahoma
For those of you that don't want red meat, the lobster accompanied with drawn-butter may be just what you are looking for. 
Facebook/bestlittlesteakhouseinoklahoma
Before you leave, you must try their homemade cheesecake with caramel drizzle. 
Facebook/bestlittlesteakhouseinoklahoma

To learn more about Rusty Barrell Supper Club, click here.

Click here to see a list of 10 more great steaks in Oklahoma.

OnlyInYourState may earn compensation through affiliate links in this article. As an Amazon Associate, we earn from qualifying purchases.

Related Articles

Explore Oklahoma

Featured Addresses
Rusty Barrell Supper Club Inc, 2005 N 14th St, Ponca City, OK 74601, USA